Best Movies for scares

scares Decision Dashboard

Safest pick

Backrooms

4.1 feature score

Balances feature score, supporting reviews, and overall product strength.

Most evidence

The Mortuary Assistant

37 supporting reviews

Has the broadest review evidence for this feature.

Best overall product

Rose of Nevada

4.5 overall score

Strongest overall product among items with scored evidence for this feature.

See ranked products
#1 Shipwrecked: Nightmare at Sea
5.0

The real-life panic, darkness, tilting ship, and delayed rescue make the documentary more frightening than many fictional horror films. The terror comes from knowing every desperate moment actually happened.

Pros: suspense, scares

Cons: pacing, character development

#2 Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man
5.0

The eerie, supernatural-leaning material is praised as some of the eeriest material the franchise has attempted.

Pros: scares, score quality

Cons: special effects quality, CGI quality

#3 Rose of Nevada
4.5

The film creates dread through sound, repetition, warnings, disorientation, and the fear of permanent separation rather than jump scares. Its horror is psychological, mournful, and quietly oppressive.

Pros: plot originality, lead performance

Cons: runtime, screenplay quality

#4 The Isolate Thief
4.5

The film creates fear through implication and anticipation, often making unseen danger as unsettling as the violence eventually shown.

Pros: ending satisfaction, soundtrack quality

Cons: family friendliness, age appropriateness

#5 Toy Story 5
4.5

The screen-addiction imagery carries an effective digital-horror edge without turning the film into something too frightening for its family audience. The unease comes more from recognizable behavior than conventional peril.

Pros: lead performance, directing quality

Cons: originality, romance quality

#6 Backrooms
4.1

The film favors sustained unease, hidden threats, and carefully placed shocks over constant jump scares. Many found it deeply creepy or terrifying, though several felt the later monster reveals and...

Pros: emotional impact, CGI quality

Cons: action sequences, dialogue quality

#7 Exit 8
4.0

The film relies more on claustrophobia, uncertainty, and accumulating dread than constant jump scares. Most found it effectively creepy, though a few said it was barely scary at all.

Pros: practical effects quality, sound design

Cons: cultural representation, CGI quality

#8 Night Nurse
4.0

The film creates dread through voyeuristic framing, caregiver intimacy, and psychological unease rather than jump scares. Its strongest horror moments are quiet, nightmarish, and suggestive.

Pros: plot originality, drama quality

Cons: realism, violence level

#9 Camp
4.0

The film favors unease, ritual imagery, and emotional dread over jump scares or a body-count structure. Its horror is soft-edged but capable of leaving a lingering chill.

Pros: world-building, emotional impact

Cons: dialogue quality, ending satisfaction

#10 Project Hail Mary
4.0

The movie includes some existentially frightening moments, but one family-oriented review still considers them manageable within an overwhelmingly hopeful adventure.

Pros: world-building, sound design

Cons: ending satisfaction, romance quality

#11 Leviticus
3.9

The film earns strong tension, a few standout jump scares, and several disturbing identity-switch set pieces. Reactions are mixed on overall fright level, with some viewers finding the supernatural element...

Pros: cultural representation, critic appeal

Cons: humor, world-building

#12 The Odyssey
3.9

The Cyclops, Circe, Hades, and body-horror imagery deliver unexpectedly effective scares, though not every fantastical threat is equally convincing.

Pros: character development, world-building

Cons: pacing, sound design

#13 Minions & Monsters
3.5

The scares are mild for most families, with several reviewers framing it as a gateway spooky movie. Parents of very young or sensitive kids may want caution around monster scenes...

Pros: ending satisfaction, acting performance

Cons: sexual content level, plot clarity

#14 Evil Dead Burn
3.1

The oppressive atmosphere and relentless attacks frightened some reviewers, but others found the movie more gross than genuinely scary. Its strongest fear comes from sustained discomfort rather than traditional suspense...

Pros: acting performance, supporting cast performance

Cons: rewatch value, emotional impact

#15 Wuthering Heights
3.0

The gothic material occasionally chills or unsettles, but some critics think the film rarely becomes genuinely dangerous or frightening.

Pros: score quality, cinematography

Cons: age appropriateness, character development

#16 Underland
3.0

The film is not conventional horror, but tight cave passages, darkness, flooding risks, and vast underground spaces may be intense for claustrophobic or agoraphobic viewers.

Pros: suspense, cinematography

Cons: character development, animation quality

#17 Passenger
2.7

The opening, projector scene, and rotating parking-lot sequence earn substantial praise, and several viewers found the film gripping. The heavy reliance on predictable, loud jump scares sharply divides opinion.

Pros: directing quality, score quality

Cons: drama quality, value for money

#18 The Mortuary Assistant
2.2

Scare effectiveness is the central disappointment for many reviewers. Creepy background figures, the Mimic, body horror, and occasional fake-outs work, but repetitive jump scares and weak buildup often keep the...

Pros: violence level, sound design

Cons: action sequences, dialogue quality

#19 Ready or Not 2: Here I Come
2.1

Reviewers who discuss the horror side often say the sequel is less frightening than the first, with action and gore replacing sustained fear. A few still find individual stretches dark,...

Pros: practical effects quality, editing quality

Cons: story quality, special effects quality