Compare Rose of Nevada vs What They Had

Rose of Nevada

Rose of Nevada

Overall score 4.5 / 5

Based on 46 scored reviews

vs
What They Had

What They Had

Overall score 4.0 / 5

Based on 28 scored reviews

How we score

Scorata scores summarize analyzed review evidence on a 1–5 scale; they are not laboratory measurements or a simple average of customer star ratings. Feature scores summarize the reviews covering that feature. The overall score averages feature scores within each review, then combines review averages. When both expert and customer evidence are available, those two groups receive equal weight. Products can have different review coverage, so small score gaps do not establish a winner.

Recommendations prioritize important features for the category, with a score of at least 3.5, a gap of at least 0.25 points and at least two supporting reviews per product. Features with widely varying scores or broad connectivity contexts are excluded from recommendations. These safeguards do not establish statistical significance.

Quick verdict

What each product is best for

The review evidence points to a tradeoff: directing quality and emotional impact versus audience appeal and acting performance. Choose according to which strengths matter more to you; the overall score alone does not settle that choice.

Choose Rose of Nevada for directing quality and emotional impact.

Choose What They Had for audience appeal and acting performance.

Why these recommendations?

Rose of Nevada

Where It Has the Edge

  • directing quality is 4.9 vs 4.3. Mark Jenkin’s control of image, sound, rhythm, and regional detail gives the film a singular identity. The uncompromising...
  • emotional impact is 4.8 vs 4.3. Nick’s separation from his wife and daughter gives the film a deep current of grief, panic, and longing....

What They Had

Where It Has the Edge

  • audience appeal is 4.2 vs 3.5. Caregivers and viewers with experience of aging parents are especially likely to recognize the dilemmas. Its family-centered sadness...
  • acting performance is 4.8 vs 4.5. The ensemble is the most reliable strength, turning strained family arguments into vivid, often moving scenes. Even skeptical...
Rose of Nevada 4.5 overall score
What They Had 4.0 overall score

Compare features

Scores are out of 5. Missing scores mean missing review evidence, not a missing feature.

Scored on both products

Comfort and build

Sound design
Rose of Nevada
4.8

The post-produced clanks, engines, gulls, waves, voices, and distorted tones are as important as the images. The mix is masterful and immersive, but it can become physically harsh or uncomfortably loud.

What They Had
2.0

Noticeable sound-mix problems distract from an otherwise emotionally involving ensemble drama.

Visual style
Rose of Nevada
4.9

Saturated primary colors, grain, scratches, cropped close-ups, rust, moss, rain, and weathered surfaces create a dense visual world. The style is beautiful, abrasive, and instantly recognizable.

What They Had
3.6

The restrained presentation can feel handsome and intimate, with evocative winter imagery. Some visual decisions fall flat, and the home-bound arguments can seem more theatrical than cinematic.

Production design
Rose of Nevada
5.0

The decaying present and busier 1993 village are built through rigorously detailed homes, pubs, docks, tools, and storefronts. The environments feel inhabited and help communicate social change without exposition.

What They Had
4.3

The family apartment feels comfortably inhabited, and the understated design is polished. Familiar domestic spaces strengthen the sense of accumulated family history.

Other features

Originality
Rose of Nevada
4.6

Using an ordinary fishing trawler and the sea itself as a time machine gives the familiar time-travel idea a fresh, grounded form. The paradoxes grow directly from work, family, and community rather than technological spectacle.

What They Had
2.1

The dysfunctional-family setup and familiar narrative beats invite repeated complaints about cliché. Strong acting helps, but does not make the plotting surprising.

Runtime
Rose of Nevada
2.1

At 114 minutes, the film gives its atmosphere and labor routines room to accumulate, but the length is a recurring complaint. Viewers less absorbed by the style may feel that a substantial portion could have been cut.

What They Had
4.5

The film’s length feels well judged in the account that discusses runtime, avoiding the drag often associated with character dramas.

Editing quality
Rose of Nevada
4.1

Rapid inserts, match cuts, flash frames, and repeated images make past and present bleed together with hypnotic force. The same method can feel overextended when the film lingers on fishing routines or withholds a conventional resolution.

What They Had
2.0

Skipping the process behind the final reconciliations makes the third act feel discordant. Brief glimpses of settled outcomes weaken the earlier patient observation.

Score quality
Rose of Nevada
4.9

Jenkin’s eerie electronic and organ-like score reinforces the sense of temporal dislocation and grief. It shifts between low menace and mournful abstraction without overwhelming the handmade soundscape.

What They Had
3.0

The musical score receives a modest assessment rather than standing out beside the performances and photography.

Theme depth
Rose of Nevada
4.7

The film layers grief, memory, identity, labor, community, nostalgia, class decline, sacrifice, and free will into its time-travel premise. Its refusal to settle on one interpretation is a strength for engaged viewers and a barrier for others.

What They Had
3.2

The film explores commitment, family roles and the burden of dementia care. Its breadth can enrich the portrait, but can also dilute the central issue or leave hard questions unanswered.

Writing quality
Rose of Nevada
2.2

The script provides a stronger narrative spine than Jenkin’s previous experiments while preserving ambiguity and thematic depth. Dissenting viewers found it unfocused, underexplained, or too conventional compared with the bold visual form.

What They Had
3.7

The writing can be observant, witty and emotionally precise about family obligation. Critics also flag banal dialogue, distracting side stories and overly convenient resolutions.

Ending satisfaction
Rose of Nevada
3.9

The open ending is one of the film’s sharpest dividing points. Some found it haunting, poignant, and endlessly suggestive, while others felt the abrupt lack of answers denied the story a needed payoff.

What They Had
2.7

The ending is the clearest fault line: restrained reconciliation moves some viewers, while others object to tidy closure, drawn-out farewells and blunt symbolism.

Romance quality
Rose of Nevada
5.0

Two love stories give the time-travel premise much of its heartbreak: one man is torn from the family he loves, while another steps into a family he never had. Their emotional imbalance deepens the film’s moral tension.

What They Had
3.8

The older couple’s enduring attachment supplies some of the most gently moving moments. Bridget’s flirtation divides opinion and can distract from the central caregiving crisis.

Story quality
Rose of Nevada
4.6

The fishing-boat time-slip offers a clear emotional hook while leaving its metaphysics unresolved. The story is compelling and moving at its best, though repetition and underdeveloped ideas weaken it for some audiences.

What They Had
3.4

The caregiving dispute creates a compelling center, but the surrounding marital and college subplots divide viewers. Some welcome the broader family portrait; others feel it crowds out dementia or resolves too easily.

Drama quality
Rose of Nevada
4.8

The supernatural premise remains grounded in a family man’s desperation, a drifter’s longing for belonging, and a community’s dependence on dangerous work. That human tension gives the film more emotional force than a conventional puzzle movie.

What They Had
4.0

The family crisis can be intimate, funny and deeply affecting, particularly when caregiving takes center stage. Conventional plotting and sentimental resolutions divide reactions.

Directing quality
Rose of Nevada
4.9

Mark Jenkin’s control of image, sound, rhythm, and regional detail gives the film a singular identity. The uncompromising vision is a major strength, though the expanded time-travel plot occasionally feels unfocused.

What They Had
4.3

Chomko is often praised for a sensitive touch and control of a difficult emotional subject. Reservations center on theatrical staging, uneven visual choices and familiar dramatic turns.

Tonal consistency
Rose of Nevada
5.0

Character drama, eerie dread, dry humor, social realism, and supernatural mystery coexist with unusual control. The tonal mixture remains coherent because every element shares the same handmade, mournful texture.

What They Had
4.4

The balance of grief and humor often keeps the drama humane and avoids mawkishness. More critical reactions find an uneasy slide toward heavy sentimentality.

Pacing
Rose of Nevada
3.3

The deliberate rhythm can feel hypnotic and more propulsive than Jenkin’s earlier work. The 114-minute running time, repeated voyages, and prolonged observational passages can also make the film drag.

What They Had
3.8

Many find the story absorbing even through repeated family arguments, with welcome breathing room. Others object to meandering subplots or an overextended ending.

Emotional impact
Rose of Nevada
4.8

Nick’s separation from his wife and daughter gives the film a deep current of grief, panic, and longing. Its quietest moments can feel heartbreaking and leave a lasting, quietly devastating impression.

What They Had
4.3

The caregiving strain, fleeting recognition and fear of separation bring many viewers to tears. Some find the emotion too heavily engineered or the overall film unexpectedly distant.

Message quality
Rose of Nevada
4.5

The film’s central message about community, sacrifice, labor, and the cost of preserving a way of life is emotionally resonant. It refuses to romanticize the past even while showing what has been lost.

What They Had
4.1

Letting go, caring for one another and acting on hard-earned lessons give the film a compassionate takeaway. One critical response finds few useful insights or believable answers beneath its sincerity.

Realism
Rose of Nevada
4.8

Fishing labor is shown as repetitive, dangerous, exhausting, and physically specific. Nets, engines, gutted fish, wet clothing, and communal unloading make the work feel immediate despite the supernatural story.

What They Had
4.5

Caregiving disputes, sibling resentment and moments of recognition often feel painfully true to life. Some question the family’s credibility or the softened picture of dementia.

Cultural representation
Rose of Nevada
4.8

Cornwall is presented as a lived-in working community rather than a scenic backdrop. The film connects fishing traditions, economic decline, local identity, and the erosion of communal life with unusual specificity.

What They Had
4.5

Chicago feels specific and inhabited rather than generic, with local atmosphere helping ground the family’s troubles.

Character development
Rose of Nevada
3.9

Nick’s fear, guilt, and devotion to his family give the film a strong emotional center, while Liam’s willingness to accept a borrowed life creates an effective contrast. Some viewers found Liam and the supporting characters less fully developed.

What They Had
3.6

The central family often feels layered, with resentment, duty and fear beneath its arguments. Smaller roles and hurried resolutions leave some relationships underdeveloped.

Dialogue quality
Rose of Nevada
4.2

The sparse dialogue is recorded after filming and often feels detached from the image, which adds to the uncanny atmosphere. Its blunt, economical exchanges fit the characters, though viewers seeking fuller explanation may find it withholding.

What They Had
3.9

Sharp exchanges and sardonic sibling shorthand give the arguments bite. Less favorable reactions hear generic, soapy lines that blunt the performances.

Genre satisfaction
Rose of Nevada
4.7

Ghost story, time-travel drama, folk tale, social realism, and experimental cinema merge into an eerie experience that resists a single label. The blend feels fresh and emotionally grounded rather than like a standard science-fiction adventure.

What They Had
5.0

For viewers seeking an emotional family drama, the blend of sadness, tenderness and comedy is especially satisfying.

Humor
Rose of Nevada
4.0

Dry humor occasionally slips through the dread, especially in Liam’s casual acceptance of impossible circumstances and the captain’s blunt sea lore. These moments lighten the film without breaking its spell.

What They Had
4.3

Gallows humor and prickly family banter provide relief without usually trivializing dementia. Laughter can feel uncomfortable, but often captures how families cope.

Cinematography
Rose of Nevada
4.7

The hand-cranked 16mm photography is the film’s most celebrated feature, turning rust, seawater, skin, and weathered buildings into tactile, saturated images. Its scratches, light leaks, and tight framing make the movie feel both newly alive and unearthed from another era.

What They Had
4.6

The photography earns praise for polished framing, painterly images and wintry Chicago atmosphere. Its restraint keeps attention on the actors.

Cast chemistry
Rose of Nevada
4.5

Nick and Liam share a restrained, almost cosmic bond shaped by hard labor and displacement. Their opposing reactions to the past create tension even when they rarely speak openly.

What They Had
4.6

Swank and Shannon’s sibling shorthand and Forster and Danner’s long-married intimacy frequently feel lived in. A minority find the family less convincing as a whole.

Ownership and support

Entertainment value
Rose of Nevada
3.0

The film can be mesmerizing when its sound, imagery, and mystery take hold, but it offers little conventional momentum or easy pleasure. Patient viewers may find it absorbing; others may simply feel bored or stranded.

What They Had
4.2

A difficult subject stays watchable through the cast’s warmth and grounded humor. Enjoyment is strongest for viewers comfortable with intimate, argumentative family drama.

Performance

Lead performance
Rose of Nevada
5.0

George MacKay and Callum Turner give the film emotional clarity by playing opposite responses to the same impossible event. Their restrained performances keep the high-concept story rooted in recognizable fear, need, and desire.

What They Had
4.2

Swank’s conflicted daughter is widely praised for making indecision and regret legible. Some find the characterization tiresome or her performance less distinctive than the supporting work.

Acting performance
Rose of Nevada
4.5

The cast embraces the deliberately restrained, post-synced performance style, and the leads make the strange premise emotionally credible. Occasional wooden stiffness feels intentional and often strengthens the uncanny design.

What They Had
4.8

The ensemble is the most reliable strength, turning strained family arguments into vivid, often moving scenes. Even skeptical takes credit the actors with lifting conventional material.

Supporting cast performance
Rose of Nevada
4.8

The supporting ensemble fits naturally into the heightened Cornish world, balancing grounded behavior with ghost-story strangeness. Francis Magee, Mary Woodvine, Rosalind Eleazar, Edward Rowe, and Yana Penrose are especially effective.

What They Had
4.9

Forster, Shannon and Danner supply many of the strongest moments, combining stubbornness, vulnerability and tenderness. The supporting ensemble often outshines the familiar plotting.

Controls and connectivity

Audience appeal
Rose of Nevada
3.5

This is Mark Jenkin’s most approachable film for many viewers, thanks to a clearer time-travel premise and recognizable leads. Its slow rhythm, fractured logic, and abrasive sound still make it best suited to adventurous art-house audiences.

What They Had
4.2

Caregivers and viewers with experience of aging parents are especially likely to recognize the dilemmas. Its family-centered sadness and humor can also connect across generations.

Evidence available for one product

Other features

Casting quality
Rose of NevadaNo score yet
What They Had
4.7

An unusually strong cast makes familiar dementia and family-conflict territory watchable. Swank, Shannon, Forster and Danner repeatedly earn praise as a group.

Dementia portrayal
Rose of NevadaNo score yet
What They Had
4.5

The shifts between confusion and clarity often feel authentic, while the family’s humor is treated as a coping mechanism. A dissenting view finds the illness softened into an overly cute screen version.

Ethical handling of deaths
Rose of NevadaNo score yet
What They Had
4.5

The third-act tragedy is handled without descending into mawkishness, preserving the film’s blunt, restrained approach.

Family dynamics
Rose of NevadaNo score yet
What They Had
4.4

The film is strongest when old resentments and genuine affection collide over caregiving decisions. That intimacy can falter when peripheral conflicts or tidy resolutions crowd the central family.

Fatherhood portrayal
Rose of NevadaNo score yet
What They Had
5.0

The father-son conflict has particular bite, exposing the damage that devotion and rigid authority can coexist with. Forster’s formidable patriarch makes that tension compelling.

Makeup quality
Rose of Nevada
5.0

Mary Woodvine’s aging makeup is convincing enough to make her difficult to recognize at first. The transformation supports the time-slip structure without feeling showy.

What They HadNo score yet
Plot clarity
Rose of Nevada
3.0

The central time-slip is understandable, but its rules, identities, and causal loops remain intentionally unresolved. That ambiguity rewards interpretation for some viewers and creates confusion or frustration for others.

What They HadNo score yet
Practical effects quality
Rose of Nevada
4.8

The modest, lo-fi effects create convincing storms, temporal ruptures, and physical danger without breaking the handmade aesthetic. Their simplicity becomes part of the film’s tactile spectacle.

What They HadNo score yet
Scares
Rose of Nevada
4.5

The film creates dread through sound, repetition, warnings, disorientation, and the fear of permanent separation rather than jump scares. Its horror is psychological, mournful, and quietly oppressive.

What They HadNo score yet
Special effects quality
Rose of Nevada
4.8

The film’s restrained effects create credible spectacle while preserving the rough, handmade look. The storm and temporal imagery feel uncanny without becoming polished or generic.

What They HadNo score yet
Suspense
Rose of Nevada
4.6

Warnings carved into the boat, shifting identities, recurring images, and the possibility of permanent entrapment keep tension simmering. The suspense is atmospheric and existential rather than plot-driven.

What They HadNo score yet

Comfort and build

Costume design
Rose of Nevada
5.0

The clothing helps distinguish the two timelines without calling attention to itself, and the period details are carefully integrated into the village setting. The costumes support the film’s immersive 1990s atmosphere.

What They HadNo score yet
World-building
Rose of Nevada
5.0

The film makes the supernatural and the everyday feel inseparable, with the village’s labor, family roles, objects, and rituals forming the rules of its temporal world. The setting feels both concrete and mythic.

What They HadNo score yet

Controls and connectivity

Critic appeal
Rose of Nevada
5.0

Its tactile craft, emotional ambition, and singular style give it strong art-house critical appeal. The pacing and narrative opacity remain the main reasons for sharp dissent.

What They HadNo score yet

Performance

Historical accuracy
Rose of NevadaNo score yet
What They Had
1.8

The family backstory and staged youthful memories draw complaints about inconsistent chronology. The Korean War connection and implied period do not convincingly fit the characters’ ages.

Soundtrack quality
Rose of Nevada
4.5

The music complements the film’s analog texture and nostalgic unease, with associations that evoke warped memory rather than comforting period nostalgia. It supports the mood more than it functions as a conventional song-driven soundtrack.

What They HadNo score yet

Ownership and support

Rewatch value
Rose of Nevada
5.0

The repeated images, causal loops, and unresolved ending invite viewers to revisit the film and form new interpretations. Several admirers found that it lingered for weeks or became richer on a second viewing.

What They HadNo score yet

Other Top Movies to Consider

#1 You Can See Everything
4.7

Choose this inventive, unsettling documentary for fearless questioning, dark humor, and unpredictable storytelling. Skip it if you want a short, straightforward exposé with definitive answers.

Pros: originality, humor

#2 Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall
4.7

A singular voice, powerful piano playing and intimate film photography make this concert absorbing for receptive listeners. Its uninterrupted, often similar-sounding songs and lack of background context are an acquired...

Pros: directing quality, cinematography

Cons: pacing, Song variety

#3 Possible Love
4.7

Extraordinary performances and richly observed relationships make this a rewarding, emotionally forceful drama. Its nearly three-hour length and slow opening demand patience and undivided attention.

Pros: class commentary, character development

#4 Chronovisor
4.7

Best for a hypnotic, bookish mystery with tactile visuals and cerebral chills. Skip it if reading-heavy, attention-demanding storytelling sounds more exhausting than exciting.

Pros: Atmosphere, cinematography

Cons: audience appeal