#1
Overall: 4.4/5
Tails' flight, Knuckles' glide and other specialized movements genuinely matter to certain puzzles. Their presence adds depth beyond a cosmetic Sonic character swap.
Pros: co-op experience, faithfulness to franchise
Cons: replay value, game length
#2
Overall: 3.3/5
Melee specialists, long-range fighters, healers, and trap users feel meaningfully different. Their weaknesses encourage positioning and varied team tactics.
Pros: character ability integration, fun factor
Cons: content variety, solo play quality