Yale August Smart Lock
Highest scored product for this attribute based on supporting review evidence.
Highest scored product for this attribute based on supporting review evidence.
Balances the attribute score, supporting reviews, and overall product strength.
Has the broadest review evidence for this attribute.
Strongest overall product among items with scored evidence for this attribute.
Keeping the outside hardware and existing deadbolt was repeatedly praised, especially for renters, maintenance access, and preserving exterior appearance.
Pros: Installation and Setup, App
Cons: Battery
Reviewers liked that the retrofit design keeps existing exterior hardware, keys, and deadbolts, making it renter-friendly and low-modification.
Pros: Installation and Setup, Industrial design
Cons: Hub requirement, Auto-lock
Existing hardware reuse scored well in the one clear opinionated case, where the lock worked with an existing strike plate and the reviewer called that nice.
Pros: Camera and doorbell performance, Installation and Setup
Cons: Keyway quality, Door compatibility (deadbolt fit)
Existing hardware reuse was a strength in the replacement scenario, where the reviewer installed it easily after removing a prior Kwikset lock.
Pros: Guest Codes and Access, Industrial design
Cons: User access management, Value and Price
One reviewer valued that the lock could mount without the kind of door drilling required by the previous lock, making the install feel friendlier to existing doors.
Pros: Battery, Smart-home integration (Alexa, Google, Siri, HomeKit, Matter, Thread)
Reviewers generally liked keeping exterior hardware and existing keys, especially for renters, though one questioned whether the retrofit concept justified the extra hardware and effort.
Pros: Installation and Setup, Value and Price
Cons: Keypad, Auto-lock
One reviewer reused an existing strike plate successfully, suggesting some prior hardware can work when the bolt alignment is already right.
Pros: Fingerprint, Value and Price
Cons: Hub requirement, Battery
Existing hardware reuse was inconsistent: one install kept the doorknob, while others noted the lock replaces more hardware or required a new handle/backplate changes.
Pros: Installation and Setup, Value and Price
Cons: Voice control, Smart-home integration (Alexa, Google, Siri, HomeKit, Matter, Thread)
Existing hardware reuse was mixed: one reviewer thought reusing the old strike would save time, but that choice made installation take longer.
Pros: Fingerprint, Installation and Setup
Existing strike reuse was a weakness in one hands-on review because the tester had to adjust the strike plate before the lock behaved correctly.
Pros: App, Guest Codes and Access
Because Lock+ replaces the full deadbolt, reviewers noted less reuse of existing keyed hardware and more friction when trying to keep old keys.
Pros: Installation and Setup, Industrial design
Cons: Value and Price, Door compatibility (deadbolt fit)
One review treated hardware reuse as a drawback because Encode replaces the whole deadbolt instead of modifying the existing one.
Pros: Installation and Setup, App
Cons: Battery, Locking motor