NCIS: New York, Season 1 Feature Scores
Explore all 69 feature scores for NCIS: New York, Season 1, organized into pros and cons.
Scores by Feature
Summary
69 reviewed features-
Very positive 4.5-5.026 (38%)
-
Positive 3.5-4.429 (42%)
-
Neutral 2.5-3.410 (14%)
-
Negative 1.5-2.44 (6%)
Pros
Sort
-
The central attraction is the easy connection between LL Cool J and Scott Caan, with Addy and Wyatt also showing promise. A few responses remain cautious about whether the new bonds can match Sam’s old partnerships.
-
Mutual respect and a welcoming attitude make Sam and Nick’s partnership appealing. Addy and Wyatt’s listening, teasing and growing trust are another promising bond.
-
Recognizable neighborhoods and on-location views make New York a lively presence. The city often feels like part of the cast, though landmarks alone do not yet provide deep urban insight.
-
The leads’ lively, sometimes spontaneous-feeling banter is a recurring strength. Their exchanges can also carry real consideration and emotion beyond the jokes.
-
Nick’s generosity, Sam’s sociability and an intriguing supporting team offer reasons to keep watching. Addy and the initially prickly Sean both win particular interest.
-
The new relationships and unresolved backstories leave many viewers eager to continue. That enthusiasm comes with expectations that the show will deepen the team and sustain its early strengths.
-
Coordinated action and shared problem-solving make the team’s competence satisfying to watch. The agents’ mutual care is as appealing as their ability to divide the work.
-
The premiere generally earns strong approval for introducing the team naturally and giving Sam a credible new beginning. Some see a solid launch rather than a major reinvention.
-
The office works best when colleagues share information, trust each other’s expertise and contribute to a common solution. Sean’s undervalued technical work complicates an otherwise supportive team culture.
-
Sam’s move to New York largely feels natural and gives the show a distinctive home. The city also helps make his decision to reconnect emotionally persuasive.
-
Sam’s history and the familiar banter create a welcome connection to earlier NCIS shows for many viewers. One video reviewer feels the branding sits on a more generic cop drama.
-
Playful banter gives the show welcome levity, while Sean and an awkward encounter from Sam’s past add comic moments. Some height jokes are corny, but the overall humor usually works.
-
The show is widely seen as a solid, sometimes better-than-expected extension, powered by its leads and setting. Its familiar cases keep it from feeling like a major leap forward.
-
Wells’s care and authority and the contrasting approaches of Sam and Nick give the office useful texture. Sean’s feeling of being undervalued exposes a weakness in that supportive image.
-
LL Cool J and Caan provide the charm and emotional substance that often lift the familiar material. Some viewers enjoy their work while still finding Caan’s persona too familiar.
-
The acting is consistently well received, with the leads supplying both engaging chemistry and credible emotional restraint.
-
The show’s banter, team bond and recognizable rhythm often recall the franchise’s earlier appeal. That familiar feeling is a major part of its enjoyment.
-
Belonging, moral disappointment and respectful disagreement give the procedural more to consider than catching a culprit. Sam’s return is strongest when it complicates his view of himself and others.
-
Wide city views and the closing skyline image give the show a strong visual identity. The bridge-side conversation is another attractive use of the setting.
-
The flag presentation and Nick’s bridge-side appeal deliver some of the strongest feeling. Later Sam-centered material can land less effectively when it repeats situations longtime viewers already know.
-
The supporting ensemble is solid, with Byers’s swagger, Harper’s fight work and Beals’s amusing authority standing out.
-
The pilot’s tribute gives its victim a warmly praised sense of closure. Episode 3 also benefits from the satisfaction of bringing endangered children to safety.
-
Sam’s resistance to settling down carries credible vulnerability. Honoring his murdered friend gives the pilot a particularly satisfying moment of mourning and closure.
-
The team’s desire to do good is part of the appeal, especially when agents save lives and show compassion to someone manipulated into crime.
-
Coordinated raids and useful computer work make the agents’ competence enjoyable to watch. Some case complications nevertheless feel designed mainly to keep the team busy.
-
Missed obligations and an encounter with a former mentor complicate Sam’s return. His reassessment of the life he left behind adds emotional substance.
-
The overseas opening gives Sam an ambitious action introduction and a meaningful disruption when professional duty costs him personal availability.
-
The coordinated bar raid and Addy’s decisive intervention make the action a highlight. The training montage is less welcome and strikes one viewer as an unnecessary echo of earlier NCIS material.
-
The familiar procedural charm and suitable pace generally satisfy expectations. A dissenting response finds the cop-drama format less distinctive than the NCIS identity it wanted.
-
Sam receives meaningful emotional depth, but supporting characters often remain sketches with promising backstories. Later episodes broaden the relationships unevenly, leaving repeated calls for more attention beyond the lead.
-
The buddy-comedy rapport lightens the investigations, while the slick presentation adds a spy-drama flavor. Both shifts are welcomed as enjoyable parts of the mix.
-
The slick, occasionally spy-like presentation and distinctive city backdrop help the new show stand apart visually.
-
Sid, the office dog, adds a warmly welcomed touch of personality to the team’s headquarters.
-
The premiere avoids the unnecessary introductory exposition that can make a new procedural feel stiff.
-
The leads can be tough, funny and openly attentive to each other. Accepting companionship is presented as compatible with strength rather than a surrender of authority.
-
Empire State of Mind works beautifully with the closing city view, giving the pilot’s final image an effective musical lift.
-
Most assessments find the show engaging and fun, often because of its team rather than its mysteries. The video response is more qualified, and an embedded commenter rejects it outright.
-
The writing earns praise when it shares meaningful work across the team and avoids automatic feuds. Recycled emotional beats and formulaic case material leave room for improvement.
-
Following up on Addy and Wyatt’s earlier conversation makes their growing trust feel sustained across episodes.
-
Having another woman lead the NCIS office is explicitly welcomed as an appealing part of the new team.
-
Episode 4’s clashes over trust and leadership provide the personal tension needed to make the team’s relationships more engaging.
-
The premiere moves at a pace that suits its energetic crime-drama format.
-
The pilot’s familiar procedural machinery runs smoothly, providing an efficient introduction to the new office.
-
Sam’s invitation to stay becomes an appealing story about accepting connection. The partnership gives institutional belonging a convincing emotional pull.
-
The handsomely lit Queensboro Bridge gives Nick’s heartfelt speech an especially attractive setting.
-
Bringing Sam into the new team gives the spinoff an established personal history to explore from its first episode.
-
Sam becomes the pilot’s clear driving force, giving the new series a confident central character from the outset.
-
The new partnership gives Sam a persuasive reason to return home and a fresh sense of purpose in the city.
-
Sam’s determination to honor his murdered friend leads to a gratifying tribute to his service and the life he lived.
-
The second episode finds real sadness in a young man whose loyalty to his brother is exploited. Family obligation becomes a destructive force rather than an easy source of support.
-
Sean’s compulsory service adds a useful complication to the office’s warm image. His place on the team contrasts meaningfully with Sam’s invitation to belong.
-
LL Cool J’s recognizable presence gives the new show an immediate draw and a clear connection for established viewers.
-
The death of Sam’s friend gives the opening investigation personal weight and makes his homecoming more than a change of assignment.
-
Addy and Wyatt have enough chemistry to suggest a future pairing. For now, the appeal rests on a promising friendship rather than an already established romance.
-
Neighborhoods give the city visual distinction and emotional associations. The pilot has not yet developed an equally detailed picture of life within those places.
Cons
Sort
-
The show stays close to familiar procedural plotting, which can feel generic or repetitive. Nick’s welcoming approach offers a refreshing variation on the usual bickering partnership.
-
A later Sam-centered emotional beat feels too much like material longtime viewers have already seen. Familiarity can weaken the intended resonance.
-
The pilot’s central investigation draws criticism for suspicious logic and a case that does not fully make sense.
-
The lack of a proper opening theme is a disappointment for a viewer who misses that part of the franchise presentation.
-
The fleeting title card feels disappointing to a viewer who wants a fuller NCIS opening sequence.
-
Positive intentions do not erase the cautions around bloodshed and profanity. Content-conscious households may find the familiar crime-drama material a significant barrier.
-
Occasional profanity is treated as a content concern that may diminish the show’s appeal for sensitive households.
-
Bloodshed is framed as a meaningful content concern. The agents’ pursuit of justice may not compensate for it for more sensitive viewers.
-
Height-based jokes can be ordinary or corny. The partnership has more appeal than those familiar gags alone.
-
Attention shifts unevenly across the team. The pilot and third episode earn praise for sharing the work, while Wells’s limited role and later emphasis on Sam prompt requests for more balance.
-
Reactions differ sharply: the pilot surprises one viewer, while episode 3’s clues and accomplice seem too obvious to another.
-
Opinions depend on the episode: some find the pilot and third hour well shared, while others see supporting roles crowded out by Sam. Developing the rest of the team remains a recurring request.
-
The character-led homecoming can be compelling, but the investigations draw complaints about crowded, formulaic or unconvincing plotting. Teamwork and relationships often carry the stronger interest.
-
Critics generally welcome the ensemble and see Caan as a strong complement to LL Cool J. Some audience comments object to casting him as a new character who feels much like his earlier roles.
Use Cases
Best for
Sort
-
Fans seeking familiar banter, Sam Hanna and an old-school NCIS feel have plenty to enjoy. Some longtime viewers miss his earlier partnerships or find the new show too generic to capture the same identity.
-
The pilot supplies enough background to follow Sam’s new circumstances without watching his earlier shows. It also works as an appealing standalone introduction to the team.
-
Sam’s homecoming and his emerging relationships give the procedural an appealing personal center. The characters can be a stronger draw than the case itself.
-
The familiar formula and easy rapport make this a comfortable return to the NCIS world.
-
Puzzle appeal varies: one viewer welcomes an unexpected pilot twist, while another finds episode 3’s culprit and clues obvious. The teamwork is a steadier attraction than the guessing game.
Cast & Creators
-
Sam HannaLL Cool J gives Sam’s homecoming charm and believable emotional vulnerability. His strongest notices praise the opportunity to play deeper material without making it grandiose.
-
Nick SchaefferCaan’s relaxed humor, charm and chemistry with LL Cool J earn strong praise, with Nick’s maturity surprising some critics. Embedded audience comments are less forgiving, seeing another version of his familiar television cop.
-
Wyatt SersHarper’s easy rapport with Byers strengthens the younger pairing, and his fight work supplies an additional highlight.
-
Addy RossByers brings swagger to Addy and an easy chemistry with Harper. Her performance helps make the younger partnership engaging from the start.
-
Robyn WellsBeals fits Wells’s authority well and makes her exchanges with Sean amusing. Her performance is a welcome part of the ensemble.