Compare Hollow Knight: Silksong vs Hillthorn

Hollow Knight: Silksong

Hollow Knight: Silksong

Overall score 4.3 / 5

Based on 28 scored reviews

vs
Hillthorn

Hillthorn

Overall score 4.3 / 5

Based on 18 scored reviews

How we score

Scorata scores summarize analyzed review evidence on a 1–5 scale; they are not laboratory measurements or a simple average of customer star ratings. Feature scores summarize the reviews covering that feature. The overall score averages feature scores within each review, then combines review averages. When both expert and customer evidence are available, those two groups receive equal weight. Products can have different review coverage, so small score gaps do not establish a winner.

Recommendations prioritize important features for the category, with a score of at least 3.5, a gap of at least 0.25 points and at least two supporting reviews per product. Features with widely varying scores or broad connectivity contexts are excluded from recommendations. These safeguards do not establish statistical significance.

Quick verdict

What each product is best for

The review evidence points to a tradeoff: character development and dialogue quality versus learning curve and innovation. Choose according to which strengths matter more to you; the overall score alone does not settle that choice.

Choose Hollow Knight: Silksong for character development and dialogue quality.

Choose Hillthorn for learning curve and innovation.

Why these recommendations?

Hollow Knight: Silksong

Where It Has the Edge

  • character development is 4.7 vs 2.3. Character development is praised for Hornet softening through Pharloom and for character arcs that counterbalance the harsh world.
  • dialogue quality is 4.3 vs 2.3. Dialogue is mixed-to-positive: one review calls it shockingly good, while another says it can feel dry at times.
  • environmental detail is 5.0 vs 4.5. Environmental detail is repeatedly praised, from dense small touches to rooms and backgrounds that make Pharloom feel lived-in.

Hillthorn

Where It Has the Edge

  • learning curve is 4.1 vs 3.3. The unusual card language can look strange or complicated at first, but it quickly becomes understandable for many...
  • innovation is 5.0 vs 4.3. The unusual card-table detective interface and almost wordless narration feel like a genuine change from familiar adventure formulas....
Hollow Knight: Silksong 4.3 overall score
Hillthorn 4.3 overall score

Compare features

Scores are out of 5. Missing scores mean missing review evidence, not a missing feature.

Scored on both products

Other features

Accessibility options
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.0

Accessibility is criticized as limited, with reviews noting the game is not trying to be accessible to everyone and lacks broader options.

Hillthorn
4.5

Adjustable card sizing and visual settings help make the small tabletop text and clues more comfortable to read.

Character development
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.7

Character development is praised for Hornet softening through Pharloom and for character arcs that counterbalance the harsh world.

Hillthorn
2.3

The townspeople are visually intriguing and often menacing, but their card-sized descriptions leave limited space for personal development. Several players wish the cast had more conversational depth.

Side character depth
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.7

Side character depth receives positive evidence from a review praising Pharloom’s supporting characters as charming and motivated.

Hillthorn
2.5

Cult members are compelling at first glance, yet their lives and motives receive little detailed exploration. More conversation would have helped their personalities breathe.

Dialogue quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.3

Dialogue is mixed-to-positive: one review calls it shockingly good, while another says it can feel dry at times.

Hillthorn
2.3

Traditional conversations are largely absent, leaving relationships to be inferred from pictures and brief labels. That helps the mystery feel unusual but can disappoint players wanting extensive character exchanges.

Immersion
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Immersion is strongly supported by one review’s comment about Pharloom lingering after play.

Hillthorn
3.4

Strong mental imagery and suspense draw some players deeply into the town, despite the limited on-screen world. Others find staring down at cards and missing conversational detail makes the setting less tangible.

Onboarding experience
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.8

Onboarding is a weak spot for some, especially in the opening hours where resources, checkpoints, and tutorial clarity are less generous.

Hillthorn
4.0

The card interactions are introduced through the same process used to investigate the world, making the learning feel natural. The first few minutes still leave room for confusion or a missed clue.

Pacing
Hollow Knight: Silksong
3.2

Pacing has a notable concern around long checkpoint placement that interrupts practice and repetition in challenging sequences.

Hillthorn
2.2

The mystery is most compelling when clues keep opening new possibilities. Multiple reviewers find its momentum weakened by rebuilding inventories and repeating familiar routes.

Learning curve
Hollow Knight: Silksong
3.3

The learning curve is steep, with reviewers noting hours of mastery and occasional git-gud walls, but also rewarding skill growth.

Hillthorn
4.1

The unusual card language can look strange or complicated at first, but it quickly becomes understandable for many players. Initial confusion and a few overlooked clues are still possible.

Progression system
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.2

Progression is generally praised for fresh upgrades and satisfying forward motion, but one review criticizes opaque true-ending requirements.

Hillthorn
3.5

The real upgrade is what the detective learns: discoveries persist even as the physical inventory resets. Some find that clever and rewarding; others think retained knowledge skips too little work.

Innovation
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.3

Innovation is positive but measured: reviewers praise new directions and system changes, while one calls it evolutionary rather than revolutionary.

Hillthorn
5.0

The unusual card-table detective interface and almost wordless narration feel like a genuine change from familiar adventure formulas. It is an especially memorable design concept, even when it introduces tradeoffs.

Animation quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Animation quality has limited but strong evidence, with reviewers noting gorgeous animation within the hand-drawn presentation.

Hillthorn
4.5

Small animated touches, such as characters represented by moving cards, bring a little movement and life to the restrained presentation.

Environmental detail
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Environmental detail is repeatedly praised, from dense small touches to rooms and backgrounds that make Pharloom feel lived-in.

Hillthorn
4.5

Subtle shadow changes and location-specific backgrounds suggest much more of the mountain than the card table directly shows. Their restrained visual cues make the surroundings feel ominous.

World interactivity
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

World interactivity has limited but strong support from one review that praises evolving locations, reactive hubs, and organic backtracking.

Hillthorn
4.5

The same cards used to inspect clues also let players explore, question people, and act on deductions. That coherence helps the stripped-back world feel interactive.

Exploration quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.5

Exploration is a standout, with most reviewers praising dense secrets, rewarding routes, and curiosity-driven discovery, though a few disliked sparse rewards or risk pressure.

Hillthorn
4.0

Alternate leads often let players move on instead of getting stuck, rewarding curiosity and self-directed investigation. Retracing familiar routes after midnight is the recurring drag.

Grind level
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.2

Grind level is criticized where resource depletion and boss attempts can push players toward needless grinding.

Hillthorn
1.8

The repeated collection of keys, items, and route steps is the clearest recurring complaint. Although shortcuts reduce some of the load, a number of players feel the clock turns discovery into errands.

Gameplay mechanics
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.3

Review evidence frames the broader mechanics as more complex than the original, especially through Hornet’s expanded combat and movement options.

Hillthorn
4.7

The small vocabulary of card actions keeps investigation manageable and makes discoveries satisfying. Its simplicity can sometimes encourage trying every combination rather than reasoning deeply.

Atmosphere
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Atmosphere is a major strength, described as surreal, haunting, dreadful, beautiful, and full of wonder and horror.

Hillthorn
4.7

A secluded cult community, oppressive imagery, shadows, and unsettling sound create an unusually potent sense of dread. Even with most of the world represented by cards, the mountain feels threatening.

Difficulty balance
Hollow Knight: Silksong
3.8

Difficulty is the most divisive attribute: many reviewers call it rewarding and intentional, while others find it cruel, too punishing, or unfairly frictional.

Hillthorn
3.5

Most puzzles ask for attention and sensible connections, not extreme leaps of logic. A few poorly signposted timing requirements and enforced repeats create spikes in frustration.

Narrative quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.7

Narrative quality is praised as more focused and engaging than the original, helped by Hornet’s voice and guided exploration.

Hillthorn
4.5

The disappearing-person mystery builds curiosity through clues and implications rather than traditional exchanges. Admirers find the restraint evocative; others miss the texture of fully developed scenes and conversations.

Art direction
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Art direction receives near-universal praise for hand-drawn beauty, color variety, style, and a distinctive visual identity.

Hillthorn
4.7

Moody portraits, stark symbols, shifting shadows, and hand-drawn card art give a sparse tabletop striking personality. The noir and folk-horror influences make even simple layouts uneasy.

Horror tension
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.6

Horror tension receives limited positive support from the dream/nightmare tone described in one review.

Hillthorn
4.8

The game generates real panic and unease using surprisingly little movement, text, or scenery. Its occult village and eerie audiovisual cues provide strong slow-burn dread.

Handheld play suitability
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.8

Handheld suitability has positive evidence from Steam Deck performance and battery life comments.

Hillthorn
5.0

The digital-board-game layout fits naturally into a handheld screen, and the presentation remains clear and responsive.

Originality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.7

Originality is praised where Silksong is seen as firmly on its own path rather than a simple copy.

Hillthorn
4.8

The detective premise is familiar, but expressing nearly everything through a card-table vocabulary gives it a distinctive identity. Even players skeptical of card games find the experiment refreshing.

Fun factor
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.6

Fun factor is high overall, with reviewers repeatedly saying they had great fun, wanted to return, or found the game compelling despite pain.

Hillthorn
4.6

The urge to chase another lead keeps many players immersed for hours and prompts enthusiastic demo reactions. Repeated collection and tighter time pressure are the main interruptions to that enjoyment.

Core gameplay loop
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

The core loop is praised as pure Metroidvania satisfaction: tough encounters, discovery, and rewarding progression through new areas.

Hillthorn
5.0

Finding a new clue usually opens another question, creating a strong urge to keep playing. The desire to understand the mountain makes long investigative sessions fly by.

Frame rate stability
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Frame rate stability has limited but positive evidence from a Switch 2 review calling 120fps performance perfect.

Hillthorn
5.0

Gameplay remained smooth in the reported PC playthrough, without noticeable stutters or frame drops.

Graphics quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Graphics quality is praised for a stunning hand-drawn world and a visual style that feels playful, dark, and richly realized.

Hillthorn
5.0

The stylized noir imagery and expressive card portraits give the game an immediately memorable look. The restrained illustrations help carry its dark themes.

Comfort and build

World-building
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.9

World-building is one of the strongest areas, with reviewers praising Pharloom as immaculate, complex, sad, and worth exploring.

Hillthorn
2.5

The mountain village hints at compelling occult history, but seeing mainly tabletops and changing light makes some of its locations feel under-realized.

Quest design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
3.1

Quest design is split: some reviewers like wishes and missions as structure, while others criticize boring or grindy fetch quests.

Hillthorn
4.5

Goals and routes are often visible early, making the satisfying part finding a clever way to achieve them. Several outcomes emerge from the same mystery rather than a rigid sequence.

Map and navigation design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.1

Map and navigation design is mixed: several reviews praise map structure and direction, but others dislike incomplete map support and 100% cleanup.

Hillthorn
3.5

Learnable routes and green travel shortcuts reduce some early confusion. However, repeating sequences of directional cards when crossing the forest can become an unnecessary chore.

Puzzle design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.5

Puzzle design receives limited but positive evidence, with one review saying Silksong makes puzzle-solving and hidden-path discovery feel effortless.

Hillthorn
4.0

Combining clues, people, objects, and action cards makes deductions approachable and frequently satisfying. Some combinations are shallow enough to solve through trial and error, and an unclear timed clue can stall the investigation.

User interface design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.5

User interface design has limited positive evidence around attractive mission HUD illustrations and attention to detail.

Hillthorn
4.1

Color coding, clear action symbols, and sorting make the tabletop readable and intuitive for most players. Occasional overlapping cards and hard-to-see clues interrupt an otherwise elegant interface.

Sound design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Sound design earns strong support from praise for surface-specific details and top-notch audio touches.

Hillthorn
4.8

Creeping background noises and environmental audio turn card interactions into threatening encounters. Changes in scene and danger are communicated effectively through sound.

Ownership and support

Value for money
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.9

Value for money is exceptional across reviews, especially because of the low price, large content volume, and long completion potential.

Hillthorn
4.0

The unusual investigation system and unsettling art are considered worthwhile at the modest launch price, especially for curious mystery fans.

Replay value
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.5

Replay value trends high for completionists and build experimenters, though one reviewer said they were glad to play it only once.

Hillthorn
4.8

Different routes and endings make the mountain worth investigating more than once. The desire to see alternative outcomes is tempered by needing to repeat old errands after resets.

Platform-specific feature support
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.6

Platform-specific support has positive evidence from ultrawide support that improves immersion.

Hillthorn
4.5

The Switch version makes good use of touchscreen input, providing a more immediate way to manipulate the many cards.

Controls and connectivity

Controls responsiveness
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.9

Control feel is strongly praised, with one review emphasizing complete control of Hornet and another calling the Switch 2 Pro Controller perfect.

Hillthorn
4.5

Direct touch input makes card selection, dragging, and dropping feel snappy on Switch hardware.

Performance

Performance optimization
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.8

Performance is praised on lower-end hardware, Switch platforms, and 120fps contexts, with only minor visual caveats.

Hillthorn
5.0

The tested PC playthrough ran smoothly, with no reported frame drops or stuttering.

Soundtrack quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

The soundtrack is one of the clearest strengths, repeatedly described as magnificent, excellent, world-class, and emotionally fitting.

Hillthorn
5.0

The music moves from relaxed, almost lounge-like tunes to ominous and affecting passages. Its shifts match the investigation and heighten emotional stakes.

Evidence available for one product

Other features

Automation
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.5

Repeated interactions eventually receive routine cards that carry out familiar actions automatically. This noticeably reduces the tedium of replaying certain steps.

Camera behavior
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.3

Camera and hitbox-adjacent behavior draws criticism where bosses or damage windows appear from off-screen or feel overly generous.

HillthornNo score yet
Card-based investigation system
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.8

Clues, characters, places, and actions are handled as cards, turning investigative reasoning into something tactile and easy to parse. Some players find the limited combinations a little too simple, but almost everyone admires the approach.

Checkpoint system
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.2

Checkpointing is a common concern, with long runbacks, sparse benches, paid benches, and poor placement repeatedly criticized.

HillthornNo score yet
Choice impact
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.7

Players can pursue separate leads, force entry, mishandle encounters, and earn very different conclusions. Consequences give the investigation meaningful agency rather than a single fixed solution.

Combat system
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.7

Combat is a major strength, described as fast, precise, tense, dance-like, and rewarding, though some reviews tie its highs to demanding difficulty.

HillthornNo score yet
Content variety
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.6

Content variety is praised through multiple game-like challenge types, many systems, and plentiful options, while remaining tied to high difficulty.

HillthornNo score yet
Crafting system
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.2

Crafting has negative evidence where shard requirements pull the player away from action into repetitive resource hunting.

HillthornNo score yet
Demo quality
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
3.9

The sample wins excitement for its inventive cards and unsettling setup. A repeated caveat is that the demo ends just as players begin to settle into its mystery.

Economy and resource balance
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.5

The rosary and shard economy is the most repeated systems complaint, often described as stingy, grindy, or slightly misbalanced.

HillthornNo score yet
Emotional impact
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.7

Emotional impact is strong, ranging from adrenaline and triumph to reviewers saying they shed tears or were moved by events.

HillthornNo score yet
Endgame content
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Endgame content receives strong support from optional endings, zones, bosses, and post-credits discoveries.

HillthornNo score yet
Enemy variety
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.1

Enemy variety is strong in scope, but evidence is mixed because flying enemies, monster rooms, and certain mobs can feel annoying.

HillthornNo score yet
Faithfulness to franchise
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.7

Faithfulness to franchise is strongly supported by reviews saying it captures, continues, and improves on Hollow Knight while standing apart.

HillthornNo score yet
Fast travel convenience
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.2

Fast travel is praised in one review for reducing backtracking tedium through well-marked routes.

HillthornNo score yet
Game length
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
3.3

An ending can arrive in just a few hours, while exploring different paths extends the experience. Some players finish satisfied; others wish there were more stories to tell with these mechanics.

Hint system
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
2.0

One crucial time-dependent clue is poorly signposted after it appears to have already served its purpose. That opacity can lead to wasteful repeat attempts.

Inventory management
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
3.0

The board must be kept organized to prevent important cards from disappearing among the clutter. The added housekeeping can make progression less seamless.

Knowledge retention and shortcuts
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.4

Passwords, learned routes, and routine cards can carry useful progress into a new day and prevent total restarts. These conveniences help considerably, although they do not eliminate item-retrieval chores.

Load times
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
5.0

Loading interruptions were minimal in the reported Switch 2 playthrough, supporting the adventure’s calm but consistent flow.

Loot system
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.0

Loot and rewards are a weaker point, with reviewers complaining about bosses or difficult paths that provide little or disappointing material payoff.

HillthornNo score yet
Lore depth
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.9

Lore depth is praised for hidden mysteries, optional heritage threads, and deeper history that rewards curiosity.

HillthornNo score yet
Movement feel
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.9

Hornet’s movement is one of the clearest consensus wins, with reviewers praising her speed, agility, sprinting, and dance-like traversal.

HillthornNo score yet
Overall quality
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
3.5

The inventive card mechanics and eerie presentation make the game worth considering, despite an oppressive loop that can detract from enjoyment.

Platforming precision
Hollow Knight: Silksong
3.4

Platforming precision is mixed: reviewers admire Hornet’s acrobatics, but several criticize the diagonal pogo or inconsistent bounce feel.

HillthornNo score yet
Polish
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.8

Polish is praised through meticulous design and presentation, though only one scored review directly supports the attribute.

HillthornNo score yet
Sandbox freedom
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.5

Several solutions and endings allow players to follow their own deductions instead of moving through a fixed chain. Freedom is limited by the small set of cards available at a given time.

Strategic depth
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
3.7

Deciding which leads to pursue before midnight gives planning real stakes. That satisfaction is reduced when a familiar item has to be fetched repeatedly instead of moving to a new deduction.

Tutorial quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
2.8

Tutorial quality is criticized through comparison with Hollow Knight’s clearer early tutorial structure and more generous opening support.

HillthornNo score yet
Upgrade system
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.3

Crests, tools, and upgrades are widely seen as flexible and creative, though a few reviews found early limitations or resource-linked tool use frustrating.

HillthornNo score yet
Visual readability
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.5

Color-coded cards and adjustable sizes make the clues easier to separate and identify. The interface generally succeeds despite occasional difficult-to-see visual details.

Writing quality
Hollow Knight: Silksong
5.0

Writing quality receives strong praise where reviewers call it top-notch and tied to Hornet’s conversations and character insight.

HillthornNo score yet

Comfort and build

Boss design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.5

Boss design is broadly praised as memorable, choreographed, varied, and exciting, though some reviews dislike spongey health pools, rewards, or runbacks.

HillthornNo score yet
Level design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.9

Level design is strongly praised for seamless area flow, purposeful rooms, thoughtful platform placement, and dense Metroidvania structure.

HillthornNo score yet
Mission design
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.5

Mission design earns positive evidence where missions give players reasons to revisit areas and make NPC discoveries feel more purposeful.

HillthornNo score yet
Time-loop design
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
3.4

Midnight restarts create urgent decisions and opportunities to act with better knowledge next time. The dividing line is repetition: returning to known locations and retrieving familiar objects can feel like busywork.

Ownership and support

Localization support
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.0

Visual interactions carry much of their meaning independently of translated dialogue, supporting play across languages. Short labels still matter when images alone are ambiguous.

Controls and connectivity

Menu usability
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.5

Even the menus use card investigations, so the control language stays consistent from setup into the mystery. That integration makes the unusual interface easier to learn.

Protagonist appeal
Hollow Knight: Silksong
4.9

Hornet is consistently praised as an excellent, charismatic, well-rounded protagonist with stronger presence than the silent Knight.

HillthornNo score yet
Touchscreen responsiveness
Hollow Knight: SilksongNo score yet
Hillthorn
4.5

Touch input lets players tap and drag cards directly, making the Switch version feel snappier than cursor-only control.

Other Top Video Games to Consider

#1 Well Dweller
4.7

Best for fluid traversal, rewarding exploration, striking art, and forgiving quality-of-life features. Skip it if you want deep combat, radical genre innovation, or consistently demanding bosses.

Pros: difficulty balance, boss design

Cons: innovation, sandbox freedom

#2 Hades II
4.5

Best for superb combat, inventive builds, and richly voiced characters. Skip it if repeated runs, resource gathering, or visually busy battles outweigh the appeal of steady progress.

Pros: overall quality, combat system

Cons: pacing, grind level

#3 Valheim
4.5

Good if you want a beautiful, demanding survival sandbox built around exploration, building, progression, and memorable co-op. Skip it if long resource runs, harsh death recovery, and deliberate pacing sound...

Pros: town-building system, exploration quality

Cons: grind level, fast travel convenience

#4 Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
4.5

Choose Clair Obscur if you want a story-rich RPG with thrilling timed combat, gorgeous art, and standout music. Skip it if poor maps, tight parry timing, or occasional bugs and...

Pros: narrative quality, combat system

Cons: map and navigation design, menu usability