Best Xbox Video Games for open-world design

open-world design Decision Dashboard

Best for open-world design

Forza Horizon 5

5.0 attribute score

Highest scored product for this attribute based on supporting review evidence.

Safest pick

Forza Horizon 6

5.0 attribute score

Balances the attribute score, supporting reviews, and overall product strength.

Most evidence

Gears of War: E-Day

15 supporting reviews

Has the broadest review evidence for this attribute.

Best overall product

Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 + 4

3.9 overall score

Strongest overall product among items with scored evidence for this attribute.

#1 Forza Horizon 5
5.0

Open-world design receives near-universal praise for its massive, varied, gorgeous Mexico map and its ability to support racing, exploration, and events.

Pros: graphics quality, accessibility options

Cons: AI behavior, difficulty balance

#2 Forza Horizon 6
5.0

The open world is the clearest consensus strength, repeatedly described as huge, dense, beautiful, and a major step up.

Pros: graphics quality, driving mechanics

Cons: world interactivity, AI behavior

#3 Doom: The Dark Ages
4.5

Semi-open design was praised for broader spaces, optional content and player choice in objectives.

Pros: combat system, weapon balance

Cons: flying mechanics, narrative quality

#4 Avowed
3.5

Open-zone design split reviewers: many liked curated, dense hubs, while others found the world restrictive, lifeless, or not interactive enough.

Pros: combat system, narrative quality

Cons: difficulty balance, enemy variety

#5 Gears of War: E-Day
3.5

The semi-open structure is divisive: some appreciate dense, compact districts that avoid a traditional open-world sprawl, while others feel the structure is awkward, repetitive, and poorly matched to Gears’ strengths.

Pros: combat system, graphics quality

Cons: exploration quality, mission design

#6 The Outer Worlds 2
3.0

Open-zone design drew mixed reactions, with compact areas praised but barren spaces and shallow depth criticized.

Pros: combat system, progression system

Cons: pacing, AI behavior

#7 Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 + 4
2.5

Open-world design scored poorly overall because multiple reviewers disliked or mourned the removal of THPS4’s freer career structure, even when they accepted the compromise.

Pros: level design, remake/remaster quality

Cons: soundtrack quality, mission design

#8 Starfield
2.0

The open-world structure disappoints reviewers who expected seamless discovery, with empty terrain and repeated outposts undercutting the sense of a living galaxy.

Pros: fun factor, combat system

Cons: bug frequency, narrative quality