The Only Living Pickpocket in New York Feature Scores
Explore all 61 feature scores for The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, organized into pros and cons.
Scores by Feature
Summary
61 reviewed features-
Very positive 4.5-5.027 (44%)
-
Positive 3.5-4.421 (34%)
-
Neutral 2.5-3.413 (21%)
Pros
Sort
-
Turturro makes Harry feel lived in through watchful eyes, small gestures, easy charm, and buried grief. Even several critics who find the story thin consider his performance the reason to watch.
-
Quiet, precise acting gives the film much of its weight. Turturro dominates, while veteran supporting players often make brief appearances count.
-
Real neighborhoods, pawnshops, diners, and subway rides give the city unusual specificity beyond Manhattan landmarks. New York often feels like a full participant in the story.
-
The supporting ensemble supplies warmth, local flavor, and concentrated emotional impact. Buscemi, Esposito, and Maslany often stand out, though some characters have too little substance.
-
Warm textures, attentive close-ups, and confident city framing make this a widely admired visual experience. The outer boroughs and final skyline images receive especially strong praise.
-
The film’s restraint, attention to ordinary behavior, and command of place win substantial praise. Its transition into higher-stakes thriller mechanics is a recurring reservation.
-
Turturro’s established rapport with Buscemi and Esposito gives their scenes an immediate shared history. His brief exchange with Maslany also generates exceptional emotional force.
-
Harry is charming, fallible, and easy to root for despite his profession. The most persuasive portraits keep his generosity and regret visible without excusing his theft or past failures.
-
The caregiving and father-daughter scenes can carry substantial grief, regret, and tenderness. A minority feel detached from the wider journey despite recognizing the power of individual moments.
-
The digital photography evokes the warmth and texture of older crime cinema without turning into a conspicuous imitation. Several critics admire how naturally the retro style fits a present-day setting.
-
The film draws warmly on street-level crime cinema of earlier decades. Many appreciate the homage for capturing a sensibility rather than simply copying familiar images.
-
A melancholy, street-level cool is one of the most consistent pleasures. The easygoing mood can remain appealing even when the crime story feels slight.
-
The roughly 88-minute length is usually welcomed as lean and economical. One dissenting view finds the brevity leaves too little time to know the characters deeply.
-
Its affection for an older New York and older filmmaking styles is a major attraction. The wistfulness usually feels humane, although some detect a touch of romanticizing the past.
-
New York-centered songs fit the film’s love and frustration with the city, with the LCD Soundsystem opener especially admired. The selections give the emotional tone an immediate identity.
-
The film finds poignancy in a skilled older man discovering that the world has changed around him. Its strongest reflections connect obsolescence with regret, dignity, and dependence on others.
-
Its best ideas connect time, responsibility, regret, and the value of human relationships. Some find those reflections moving, while others want more depth or a less familiar treatment.
-
The clash between cash-era skills and digital crime gives the film humor and poignancy. It works best as a humane reflection on adaptation, although Harry’s technological ignorance can feel overstated.
-
Many enjoy the short film’s deliberate, breezy rhythm or find it surprisingly brisk. Dissenters experience meandering stretches and too little urgency for a story built around a deadline.
-
Most find an engaging, breezy watch driven by performance and city atmosphere. More reserved responses enjoy individual elements without finding the whole film exceptional.
-
The jazz-and-funk score is widely appreciated for its loose, old-school city mood. Its limited escalation during dangerous passages is the main musical complaint.
-
Technology confusion, generational friction, and dry exchanges provide effective laughs. The humor generally supports the melancholy instead of overwhelming it.
-
Harry’s damaged family bonds supply some of the film’s most affecting moments. The brief daughter encounter reveals the lasting cost of his choices.
-
It succeeds most consistently as an intimate crime drama with wit and an old-fashioned feel. Its caper pleasures work best when they remain connected to character.
-
The veteran ensemble and Turturro’s fit for the lead are widely admired. Price’s suitability as the threat and the casting of a late surprise role are more divisive.
-
The script can convey character and a changing city through small details rather than explanation. Convenient coincidences, familiar backstory, and a neatly engineered finale trouble several critics.
-
Many find a rich portrait in Harry’s routines, gestures, and relationships. Others think his contradictions and the supporting characters remain too thin, with the daughter scene hinting at depth the rest of the film rarely matches.
-
The restrained personal drama is strongest when small gestures and quiet exchanges carry the feeling. Its human scale gives the story weight beyond the criminal predicament.
-
Harry’s daily devotion to Rosie gives his choices a tender, personal dimension. The care is valued as a source of love and atonement rather than simply background motivation.
-
The modest theft-and-retrieval premise works best as a vehicle for Harry’s character and relationships. Reactions weaken when the chase feels predictable, overcomplicated, or less compelling than the personal story.
-
The gentle, wistful mood often holds comedy and sadness together beautifully. Some find the later move toward family drama or thriller stakes less smooth.
-
The ending can feel soulful, moving, and visually inspired. Others find its plotting overcalibrated or its surprise encounter less natural than the scenes before it.
-
Rosie’s lack of speech and movement is handled with notable sensitivity. Small expressions and stillness preserve a sense of her inner life.
-
Sharp inserts reveal how events happened without spelling everything out, and the joined locations preserve a convincing world. The editing helps make the compact story feel precise.
-
The opening efficiently introduces Harry through observation and carries a strong musical impact. It is praised for conveying character before much needs to be said.
-
The pickpocketing has slick, satisfying precision, and the later caper mechanics can stay pleasantly breezy. Watching Harry work is often more rewarding than the conspiracy around him.
-
Harry’s understated coat gives him a dapper, sophisticated silhouette while helping him blend into the crowd. Its practical design fits the precision of his trade.
-
Old professional and personal connections feel convincingly lived in. The easy banter and mutual respect help make the friendships warmer than routine crime-story alliances.
-
Some admire the plainspoken exchanges and economical meaning, while others hear flat or recycled lines. The daughter scene is particularly divisive as writing, despite frequent praise for its acting.
-
Shooting in real outer-borough locations adds tangible richness to the small-scale production.
-
The ticking clock and uncertain consequences generate tension for some. Others remain too comfortable in the jazzy, unhurried atmosphere to feel much danger.
-
The late surprise appearance gets enthusiastic praise from some and feels out of place or miscast to others. Its success depends on how naturally the final confrontation fits the preceding character study.
-
Turturro’s New York accent is praised as an effective, natural part of bringing Harry to life.
-
One enthusiastic assessment finds the film easy and breezy enough to recommend widely.
-
Turturro’s deft comic timing makes Harry’s small reactions and understated behavior especially effective.
-
The small supporting roles make Harry’s world feel populated and alive, even with the lead at the center of nearly every scene.
-
The restraint is praised: violence works as pressure rather than spectacle. The crime story can retain force without leaning on bloodshed or gratuitous on-screen brutality.
-
The film’s overall sound presentation receives positive notice alongside its visuals and funky music.
Cons
Sort
-
Several memorable actors have only a little material to work with. Critics who want deeper relationships especially regret how briefly the daughter and other supporting figures appear.
-
A few critics find the deadline personal and tense, especially through Harry’s relationships. More skeptical responses find the villain unthreatening or the urgency too manufactured to feel real.
-
One dissatisfied response finds the emotional connection too weak to inspire revisiting or sharing the film.
-
One viewer repeatedly stumbles over the long title and finds it cumbersome to say.
-
One viewer finds the long title cumbersome to say, making it a minor annoyance around an otherwise highly enjoyable film.
-
The mix of reflective drama and crime thriller is not seamless for everyone. Some find the mechanics distract from the personal story or the danger never quite emerges from the relaxed mood.
-
The young antagonist is a major dividing point. His entitled unlikability works for some, while others see a thin, implausible, or insufficiently intimidating obstacle.
-
Strong atmosphere and performance leave a worthwhile impression for some. Others regard the film as pleasant but slight rather than a lasting standout.
-
One assessment welcomes the story’s inviting directness, while another finds the cryptocurrency mechanics more complicated than necessary.
-
Some enjoy the film’s sleight of hand and eventual surprises. A dissenting view finds the plot telegraphs its moves too clearly.
-
The performances and ordinary interactions often feel naturally human. Extreme technological ignorance, convenient deadlines, and some late plot developments can strain credibility.
-
The family material divides opinion: one view finds it superfluous or familiar, while another sees it as the beautiful emotional center of the film.
-
Its humane, contemporary take on an old-fashioned crime movie feels fresh to many. Others see a familiar framework whose pleasures come mostly from execution and performance.
Use Cases
Best for
Sort
-
Locals are particularly well placed to enjoy the neighborhood texture, borough travel, and recognizable city rhythms. The authentic setting can feel like a personal pleasure beyond the crime plot.
-
Enthusiastic recommendations call this a worthwhile cinema trip, with its performances and city photography helping justify seeing it on a screen.
-
Especially rewarding for viewers who enjoy subtle performance and expressive detail. Turturro’s work can make the film worthwhile even when the story or thriller elements fall short.
-
A strong fit for viewers who enjoy throwback crime stories built around personality, atmosphere, and reflection. The relaxed rhythm rewards interest in Harry more than a demand for constant action.
-
A recommendation for lovers of cinema emphasizes confident camerawork, excellent actors, and the feel of an earlier independent-film era.
-
An explicit recommendation highlights its old-school, character-driven crime story as especially appealing for dads, with enough charm for their children too.
-
The reunion of familiar veteran actors gives the reflections on age and regret particular force for viewers with a longer memory of New York cinema.
Conditional or not ideal for
-
Thriller fan viewingViewers expecting a forceful, exciting thriller may find the relaxed mood underwhelming. The main attraction is a quiet character portrait rather than sustained adrenaline.
-
International-audience viewingThe film remains accessible, but one international perspective finds its city-specific culture more immediately rewarding for Americans and New Yorkers.
Cast & Creators
-
Harry LehmanHis restrained physicality and expressive eyes convey a lifetime of regret without grand speeches. The performance repeatedly earns career-best or awards-worthy praise and often carries the weaker material.
-
KellyMaslany makes a powerful impression in a single father-daughter encounter. Her wounded intensity and emotional precision frequently turn that brief exchange into the film’s standout scene.
-
DirectorSegan earns praise for intimate observation, economical storytelling, and an authentic feel for New York. Some find his handling of thriller urgency and the final-act construction less assured.
-
BennyBuscemi brings warmth, easy familiarity, and finely judged character detail to the pawnbroker. His rapport with Turturro makes their shared history feel immediate.
-
WarrenEsposito lends the detective steadiness, authority, and a relaxed connection with Harry. His veteran ease makes their exchanges feel like old acquaintances catching up.
-
CinematographerLevy’s framing, camera movement, and textured city images make streets and storefronts feel alive. His outer-borough views and harbor imagery draw particular admiration.
-
ComposerThe jazzy, funky score supplies old-school cool and a strong sense of place. A few critics wish it grew more urgent when the story becomes dangerous.
-
ActorHer brief late appearance delights some with its memorable impact. Other assessments of the praised ensemble place more emphasis on how little room the supporting players receive.
-
ActorChinn adds charm and a vivid, cantankerous presence to the Chinatown encounters.
-
ActorHis shopkeeper contributes effective character work and a distinctive piece of the film’s neighborhood texture.
-
ActorAgba’s neighbor helps give the city portrait a distinctive, everyday human texture.
-
His trembling vocal delivery gives the opening song a raw vulnerability that strengthens its emotional impact.
-
RosieArroyave’s immobile, non-speaking performance is praised for sensitive handling of a demanding role.
-
ActorHis young pickpocket adds another lively human detail to the film’s portrait of New York.
-
ActorHe contributes to an appreciated supporting ensemble, though the film gives its smaller roles limited room.
-
Dylan DiamondPrice divides opinion sharply: some admire the antagonist’s nuance or committed unlikability, while others find him miscast, exaggerated, or too lacking in menace to sustain the stakes.