Overall Scorata score: 3.6/5
Based on 12 analyzed reviews · View source samples
Explore all 56 feature scores for Dig, organized into pros and cons.
Scores by Feature
Summary
56 reviewed features-
Very positive 4.5-5.06 (11%)
-
Positive 3.5-4.419 (34%)
-
Neutral 2.5-3.419 (34%)
-
Negative 1.5-2.412 (21%)
Pros
Sort
-
The cast often carries material that is less assured than the performances. Enthusiasm for the ensemble is tempered by occasional miscasting and roles that limit comic energy.
-
The central ensemble is a major strength, with Strazza especially prominent. Some reservations concern the difficult lead, uneven role fit and characters that constrain otherwise appealing performers.
-
The developing bonds among unlikely colleagues are a recurring strength, growing into a warm found family as the group starts working together.
-
The women support one another without the love triangle collapsing into possessiveness or catfights. Their cooperation gives the series its strongest emotional foundation.
-
Contrasting female personalities increasingly mesh into an effective comic group. Romantic chemistry is less dependable, especially around Gary, and one critic finds the relationships fail to spark.
-
Several critics see enough talent and warmth to want more seasons. That promise depends on deepening the characters and building on the strongest comic material.
-
The women’s different life stages create a welcome range of perspectives. Their connections work best when the show explores personal wants rather than generational stereotypes.
-
An amiable hangout mood and deliberately gentle stakes make the show pleasant company, particularly when it eases away from plot mechanics.
-
Patty’s fumbling and simple business such as chasing sheep generate reliable amusement, often more effectively than the larger mystery.
-
Familiar guest faces add welcome variety and several memorable turns. Some appearances feel too brief or underwritten to fulfill their comic potential.
-
Novak and Mantzoukas add memorable comic energy. Reactions to other supporting turns are less consistent, with complaints about a flat donor character and curtailed guest arcs.
-
Smart jokes and well-delivered one-liners provide reliable bright spots, even when the overall comedy feels modest.
-
The core women become endearing company, particularly Patty. Elise’s prickliness and some familiar or overly restrained personalities can make the early episodes harder to embrace.
-
The likable cast and easygoing setting make an appealing diversion for many. Others find the result flat or underwhelming given the talent behind it.
-
Shared work brings contrasting personalities together in satisfying ways. The show is strongest when its central women cooperate in earnest.
-
The archaeological workplace is a fresh sitcom setting, but familiar character archetypes and romantic complications temper that novelty.
-
Patty’s growth and the women’s emerging connections create warmth and some effective emotional beats. The show does not consistently reach the deeper poignancy its setup suggests.
-
The ensemble and Novak’s romantic casting earn strong praise. Other reactions question whether the performers fully match their characters’ intended edge or generational differences.
-
Elise’s shift from weary exasperation toward warm leadership is a rewarding transformation.
-
Feeling like an outsider and finding connection receive a resonant treatment as the women become friends.
-
Deft twists are a bright spot in scripts that also contain smart jokes, even when other elements prove uneven.
-
The protagonist’s rediscovery of herself through new friendships gives the comedy a resonant emotional thread.
-
The comedy makes an unfamiliar archaeological workplace approachable without requiring specialist knowledge of ancient civilizations.
-
The strongest workplace material focuses on people committed to serious work that the wider world does not always value.
-
The setting supplies picturesque scenery and attractive coastal glimpses. Those pleasures are tempered by a broader soundstage impression in one assessment.
Cons
Sort
-
Neville shifts between mentor, goofball and antagonist without a stable center. Elise’s quick softening also weakens the sharper personality introduced in the pilot.
-
The opening stretch is clunky and comparatively unfunny, with broad personalities and setup taking precedence over confident comedy.
-
Laurie takes a back seat despite his comic appeal. Some regulars receive substantial screen time without enough meaningful material to justify it.
-
The mystery usually creates less tension than its secret discovery promises. One enthusiastic assessment finds a steadily deepening puzzle, while several others call it slack or superficial.
-
Gentle stakes can make pleasant escapism, but they also leave the mystery and drama feeling lightweight or uncertain.
-
Comedy, romance, drama and mystery compete for attention. The mix can support resonant friendships, but several critics find it too diffuse to deliver strongly in any one mode.
-
Heavy reliance on Greek stereotypes and the handling of the largest Greek role weaken the cultural portrayal.
-
The dramatic side feels too lightweight to supply much substance alongside the already diffuse comedy and mystery.
-
Individual episodes struggle to bring their plots to a satisfying finish, making their running time feel stretched.
-
Heavy introductory dialogue tells characters things about themselves without making their personalities feel clearly defined.
-
Hackneyed fat jokes weaken the early comedy and feel out of step with the show’s warmer intentions.
-
The relentlessly bright lighting, including nighttime scenes, makes the presentation feel excessively light and visually unvaried.
-
The real-location sequences do too little to overcome the broader impression of an artificial Greek setting.
-
The opening flash-forward jumps ahead before establishing the characters, making the setup disorienting and difficult to invest in.
-
The heavily used excavation trenches look artificial, giving much of the show an unconvincing soundstage feel.
-
The characters’ unexplained lives outside the summer dig make their professional situation feel insufficiently thought through.
-
Patty’s heightened vocal fry initially contributes to a caricatured impression, even as her broader characterization improves later.
-
Flashbacks can help flesh out relationships, but the early flash-forward and scattered competing threads can leave the storytelling fragmented.
-
The secret discovery provides a workable caper, especially once the women unite. Several critics find the competing grudges, romances and mystery less engaging than simply spending time with the cast.
-
Female friendship, loneliness and reinvention give the show meaningful moments. Several critics still find its broader purpose thin compared with the creators’ more ambitious work.
-
The season spends too long establishing its group for some tastes. Momentum improves once the women unite around their secret project.
-
Curiosity about the next development can keep the episodes playing, though the impulse comes more from the hooks than from consistently rewarding comedy.
-
Small late twists sustain curiosity and encourage another episode. They provide forward motion without resolving the weakness of the material between them.
-
The warm ensemble tone works best once the show settles. Early fat jokes and an uncertain balance of sentiment and comedy make that tone feel less coherent to some.
-
The compact format can feel refreshingly manageable. A dissenting view finds even the roughly half-hour episodes strain to fill and resolve their plots.
-
The flashbacks divide opinion: they can enrich shared histories, but they can also interrupt the story with unnecessary old grudges.
-
Smart jokes and richer female characters emerge from an uneven script. Thin plotting, inconsistent characterization and overly cute romances keep it from feeling consistently sharp.
-
The dig offers an accessible introduction to an unusual profession. Its appeal is limited when the mystery sidelines the actual work and the passion behind it.
-
Poehler and Novak can generate welcome romantic charge, and the love triangle avoids petty rivalry. Other reactions find the romances too cute, lacking chemistry or short on meaningful conflict.
-
Strazza’s awkward energy and the ensemble’s contrasts supply the strongest laughs. Reactions range from delightful comedy to a show that settles for small chuckles or feels painfully unfunny.
-
Some find satisfying growth as broad personalities reveal vulnerabilities and form friendships. Others feel most of the ensemble stays fuzzy, with Patty receiving the clearest and most rewarding arc.
Use Cases
Best for
Sort
-
An unusual profession and a likable, mismatched ensemble make this a worthwhile workplace hangout. Expectations of nonstop laughs or the creators’ sharpest sitcom work should be moderated.
-
The supportive, intergenerational bonds among the women make this especially appealing for viewers drawn to stories of friendship and found family.
-
The breezy tone, charm and modest commitment suit casual watching without requiring heavy concentration.
-
Fans can enjoy the reunion and a familiar affection for oddball colleagues and unlikely friendships. The characters and comic sharpness do not consistently match the earlier show.
-
Patty’s first friendships, early romance and growing confidence form a particularly rewarding coming-of-age thread with both comic and emotional appeal.
-
The low-pressure storytelling and familiar warmth suit a comforting escape. Its appeal comes more from spending time with the group than from urgent plotting.
-
The half-hour format offers satisfying entertainment without demanding a large block of time or mental effort.
-
Its pleasant, low-demand comedy works well alongside household chores, although that ease also reflects its limited ambition.
-
The series works best as a group hangout about people devoted to an undervalued pursuit, making the ensemble more appealing than the mystery.
-
Viewers willing to sit through a rough setup can be rewarded by stronger friendships and more confident momentum later in the season.
Conditional or not ideal for
Sort
-
Mystery-solving viewingThe secret artifact and escalating caper may satisfy viewers who want a light puzzle alongside comedy. Those seeking gripping suspense or intricate mystery construction are more likely to be disappointed.
-
Comedy-fan viewingThe eccentric ensemble has enthusiastic supporters, but the laugh rate is divisive. Viewers seeking sustained, big laughs may find it too gentle or uneven.
-
Romantic-comedy fan viewingViewers seeking strong romantic heat may be disappointed by overly cute scenes and an unconvincing central triangle.
Cast & Creators
-
ElisePoehler can make Elise’s growing warmth and contrasting friendships a joy to watch. Her glum starting point and naturally sunny presence feel poorly matched to the intended edge for some critics.
-
PattyStrazza supplies many of the biggest laughs and strongest emotional moments, making Patty an endearing center of the show. Her broad innocence and heightened delivery occasionally feel caricatured before the character settles.
-
CreatorSchur’s affection for mismatched colleagues and meaningful friendships remains appealing. His latest collaboration also draws criticism for shallow themes, uncertain genre balance and comedy below his best work.
-
NevilleLaurie’s pompous charm and acerbic delivery are consistent pleasures. His versatility remains appealing even when Neville’s writing changes direction too often.
-
StavrosNovak is a welcome, memorable addition whose comic charm makes an unlikely romantic lead work. His pairing with Poehler is a particular source of enthusiasm.
-
DylanViswanathan makes Dylan’s chaotic energy endearing and delivers strong comic contrasts with her co-stars. Her one-liners remain enjoyable even when the writing is uneven.
-
ClareThomas draws humor from Clare’s restraint and can be an excellent poised foil to Viswanathan. One critic finds she does not convey the intended age distinction within the group.
-
ActorMantzoukas contributes memorable, amusing supporting work. One critic likes the talent but finds the apparent guest arc too curtailed to capitalize on it.
-
ActorHis supporting turn divides opinion: one critic enjoys the familiar guest presence, while another finds the obnoxiously wealthy donor falls flat.
-
The creative collaboration is praised for delivering a worthwhile, highly entertaining story with a strong ensemble.
-
ActorHis guest appearance has promising talent behind it, but the material feels as though a fuller arc was cut short.
-
GaryThe central romantic triangle does not establish convincing chemistry between his character and either woman.