#1
Angelina Jolie gives a vulnerable, controlled, and often transfixing performance as Maxine. Her emotional precision is the film’s clearest strength and frequently keeps thin material compelling.
Pros: emotional impact, lead performance
Cons: character development, screenplay quality
#2
Jolie’s direction gets one emphatic endorsement and repeated praise for the opening attack and select visual choices. Most critics, however, find the overall approach too stiff, heavy-handed, vague, or structurally...
Pros: acting performance, cinematography
Cons: directing quality, story quality