Other features
Achievement list quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.7
Masks, challenges and objectives tied to difficulty and stealth add useful goals beyond a single successful extraction.
Art direction
Marathon
4.4
The loud retro-futurist art direction is one of the game’s defining traits. It is often gorgeous, vibrant, and refreshingly distinctive, though the color and visual density can be overwhelming.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Atmosphere
Marathon
4.3
Tau Ceti IV has a distinctive uneasy atmosphere, mixing bright retro-futurism with abandoned spaces, corporate menace, and creeping dread. The contrast makes the world memorable even before combat starts.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Character roster
Marathon
4.2
The six main Runner shells plus Rook support noticeably different playstyles through movement, stealth, healing, defense, and utility. Their identities are useful and varied even when some archetypes feel familiar.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Class balance
Marathon
2.0
Shell balance needs tuning. Assassin can feel overpowered, while Recon can lag behind stronger defensive and offensive options.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Co-op communication
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0
Calling out guards, protecting the drill operator and coordinating an escape are central to success. Voice coordination gives these jobs their best tension and humor.
Co-op role balance
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.4
Human crews can divide shooting, hacking, drilling and hauling effectively, with loadouts encouraging specialization. Fixed character identities matter less than the perks and gadgets each person chooses.
Combat mode flexibility
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.5
Switching between stealth, direct assaults or hybrid approaches is a major part of the appeal. In practice, alarms often force players into the loud option.
Community features
Marathon
3.8
Proximity chat and lightweight communication can create memorable truces or help clear up intentions, but the wider culture remains heavily shoot-on-sight. Social cooperation is possible rather than encouraged.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Companion AI
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.4
Bot partners frequently fail to guard the drill, handle objectives or help carry loot, making solo play frustrating. Occasional healing or bag pickup helps, but does not fully replace a crew.
Competitive balance
Marathon
2.1
Competitive balance is most satisfying when teams and gear are evenly matched. Skill gaps, gear gaps, and uneven squad sizes can create lopsided fights that feel decided before tactics have a chance to matter.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Crafting system
Marathon
4.5
Build-crafting through mods and gear is flexible and satisfying, and the lack of extra crafting chores keeps the loop moving. The main tradeoff is that very short firefights can make some carefully built bonuses feel less important.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Economy and resource balance
Marathon
4.3
Materials and faction economies give players useful goals beyond simple kills, while barter rewards make salvage feel valuable. The better implementations keep resources circulating without completely removing the consequences of losing gear.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Emotional impact
Marathon
4.8
Successful extractions and close fights can produce unusually physical reactions—shaking hands, pounding hearts, relief, and triumph. The risk of losing gear gives victories and defeats more emotional weight than a routine shooter match.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Endgame content
Marathon
4.1
Cryo Archive is the standout endgame attraction, combining tougher AI, puzzles, high-value gear, bosses, and heavy PvP pressure. Its weekend-only access is repeatedly questioned despite the activity itself earning strong praise.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Environmental detail
Marathon
4.8
Maps reward close attention with environmental details that support both atmosphere and storytelling. The strongest spaces feel deliberately built rather than like generic combat arenas.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Exploration quality
Marathon
4.2
Exploration is rewarding when maps reveal vents, tunnels, locked rooms, hidden loot, and secrets. Some early areas become familiar too quickly, reducing the sense of discovery over time.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Frame rate stability
Marathon
4.9
Frame rates are consistently described as stable, including solid 60fps console performance and smooth higher-end PC results. Dropped-frame complaints are rare in the scored material.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Full-body avatar presence
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.5
Showing only floating hands rather than a complete body is a repeated immersion complaint, especially when trying to see an outfit or interact physically.
Gameplay mechanics
Marathon
3.9
The underlying systems are layered and often rewarding, especially once builds, faction goals, and extraction risks start working together. Some mechanics can clash with the very short time-to-kill.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Grind level
Marathon
2.7
The grind is substantial and central to Marathon’s identity. Some players enjoy faction progression and long-term goals, while others find repetitive quests and time demands exhausting.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Horror tension
Marathon
3.9
Tension is one of Marathon’s best tools: quiet looting can turn into a lethal encounter in seconds, and solo Rook runs can feel like survival horror. For some players that pressure becomes frustration rather than excitement.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Innovation
Marathon
3.7
Progression ideas, Cryo Archive, and the interaction between PvP and extraction systems show real cleverness. Still, the broader extraction-shooter direction can feel more trend-following than groundbreaking.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Inventory management
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0
On-body holsters and a small pop-up item selector keep useful supplies accessible without constantly obstructing the view.
Learning curve
Marathon
2.3
The learning curve is steep and sometimes brutal, but many players say the game becomes far more rewarding once its systems click. That delayed payoff is a strength for committed players and a major obstacle for casual ones.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Load times
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0
Returning to the hub and loading back into a heist after a failed stealth run makes retries needlessly slow.
Loot handling
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
3.3
Lifting bags adds stakes because carrying loot slows movement and restricts weapon use, making teamwork meaningful. Some hand interactions and bot bag handling are clumsy or inconsistent.
Loot system
Marathon
4.1
Loot creates the stakes that make extraction exciting, and modular gear can produce genuinely valuable finds. Losing a prized kit is thrilling when the system clicks and deeply frustrating when deaths or inventory friction feel unfair.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Lore depth
Marathon
3.9
Lore is unusually deep for a competitive shooter, with factions, AIs, codex entries, and ties to the original games creating a dense mystery. Players willing to read and connect clues get much more from the world than those who ignore it.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Matchmaking quality
Marathon
2.3
Matchmaking quality depends heavily on who fills the squad. Coordinated friends are preferred, while random teammates can make runs miserable even when the technical act of matchmaking works reliably.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Microtransaction impact
Marathon
3.5
Paid extras are mostly cosmetic and do not appear to create a serious pay-to-win problem. The bigger concern is the quality and pricing of the store and rewards pass rather than direct gameplay power.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Minigame quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.1
Safe dials, drill calibration and hacking are praised for giving VR players something physical to do during a robbery. Others find the tasks shallow, awkward or occasionally too easy.
Mission briefing repetition
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0
Unskippable, repeated spoken instructions become aggravating when teams retry missions often.
Monetization fairness
Marathon
3.5
Monetization earns mixed-to-negative reactions: expensive cosmetics and a weak rewards track draw criticism, but the lack of meaningful pay-to-win advantages is a clear positive. The base game is not gated by paid maps or abilities.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Objective clarity
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0
A player struggles to work out an interaction during a heist, illustrating how objective steps can be unclear amid the action.
Onboarding experience
Marathon
2.2
Onboarding is one of the biggest barriers. Dense menus, limited guidance, unclear objectives, and unfamiliar extraction systems can make the first several hours feel much harder than the later game.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Online stability
Marathon
5.0
Connections are generally stable, with few disconnect-style problems surfacing during long sessions. Online reliability is much less troublesome than the game’s UI or balance.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Originality
Marathon
4.3
Marathon feels most original in its audiovisual identity, corporate sci-fi setting, and the way it reshapes extraction-shooter conventions. Some class and genre elements are familiar enough to keep it from feeling wholly new.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Overall quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3
A compelling VR adaptation whose cooperative thrills outweigh its rough spots for many. Less enthusiastic players point to the thin AI, inconsistent stealth and limited environmental freedom.
Platforming precision
Marathon
2.0
Jumping and climbing can feel smooth when the geometry cooperates, but mantling is inconsistent enough to cause failures at bad moments. Ledge grabs are the clearest point of frustration.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Sandbox freedom
Marathon
4.5
Players can often choose how much danger to accept, from quietly looting and extracting to chasing tougher events or fights. That flexibility is a major part of the appeal for players who dislike being forced into constant combat.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Seasonal content quality
Marathon
4.5
Season 1’s early content is described as a fun addition, with extra rewards and activities fitting naturally into normal play. The longer-term seasonal cadence still has more to prove.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Social features
Marathon
3.9
Friends, proximity chat, and coordinated squads can produce some of the game’s best moments. Solo-focused players also point out that finding a dependable group is harder than it should be.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Solo play quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.8
Solo jobs lose the communication and division of labor that make heists shine, and AI teammates often struggle to compensate. Easier settings can be manageable, but most recommend bringing friends.
Spawn placement
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0
Cops sometimes appear abruptly in view, distracting from combat and breaking the illusion of a believable heist.
Visual effects quality
Marathon
4.5
Shield breaks and explosive hits provide satisfying visual feedback during combat. Those effects help gunfights feel punchy without needing elaborate spectacle.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
VR heist interactions
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0
Wrist-based hacking, drill controls, safe dials and on-body equipment make heists feel purpose-built for a headset. These tactile details are a consistent highlight.
VR implementation
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3
Manual reloads, wrist hacking, safe manipulation and physically carrying loot make this more immediate than traditional Payday. Some interactions remain oddly restricted and limit the full VR fantasy.
VR weapon handling
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.1
Manually manipulating guns and reloading is often satisfying and tactile. Early builds and some launch impressions also describe awkward interactions, imprecise spread or simplified handling.
Weapon variety
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3
Rifles, pistols, shotguns, SMGs and multiple tiers offer a useful arsenal for different roles. Some wish there were more genuinely distinct weapons rather than upgrades of the same base models.
Writing quality
Marathon
4.5
Faction introductions and story moments benefit from sharp, personality-driven writing. The strongest dialogue and briefings make the corporations and AIs feel distinctive rather than like generic quest dispensers.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Performance
Audio settings
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0
The inability to adjust voice-chat volume is a specific missing control that can make multiplayer audio less flexible.
Ownership and support
Battle pass value
Marathon
2.4
The first battle or rewards pass is a weak point, with recolors, duplicate items, and underwhelming cosmetics drawing criticism. Its non-expiring, low-pressure structure is one of the few positives.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Cross-play support
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0
Cross-platform play makes it easier for players on supported VR systems to join the same heist with friends.
DLC value
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0
The promise of free future heists is repeatedly welcomed because it can expand the mission pool without splitting the player base behind paid maps.
Platform-specific feature support
Marathon
4.5
PS5-specific features are used well, especially the strong DualSense haptics and PS5 Pro image treatment. These additions reinforce the already strong presentation rather than changing the core game.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Server reliability
Marathon
4.0
Servers held up well during play, with no major reliability problems standing out. The bigger uncertainty is long-term population and support rather than immediate server stability.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Comfort and build
Boss design
Marathon
4.0
Cryo Archive gives boss encounters real endgame weight, with difficult fights and a final encounter that can feel worth the preparation. Bosses are most effective when combined with the map’s PvP and puzzle pressure.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Build variety and synergy
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.6
Custom loadouts, gadgets and team-oriented perks give crews tactical choices and let members specialize. This flexibility adds purpose to preparation and repeat heists.
Control input comfort
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0
Safe dialing can require uncomfortable wrist twisting, particularly when trying to complete the combination under pressure.
Enemy design
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.5
Criticism centers on bullet-spongy foes and difficulty that scales durability rather than tactical intelligence.
Multiplayer design
Marathon
3.9
Multiplayer is aggressively PvP-focused, with trios, solo play, and emerging duo options producing very different experiences. Squad play can be excellent, while solo and mismatched team sizes expose some of the game’s harshest tradeoffs.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Quest design
Marathon
3.3
Questing gives the extraction loop direction and steady progression, yet the structure can be restrictive and grindy. Fetch-style objectives, poor signposting, and one-at-a-time progression are common pain points.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
User interface design
Marathon
1.8
The interface is the most consistent criticism. Menus, inventory icons, loot management, and information density are stylish but frequently described as cluttered, confusing, or unnecessarily hard to use.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
VR comfort settings
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3
Standard comfort controls, holster placements and seated-friendly options make the game adaptable. Some additional fine-tuning would still be welcome.
World-building
Marathon
4.7
Corporate factions, environmental storytelling, and sci-fi lore give Tau Ceti IV a strong sense of place. The world-building is often praised as unusually rich for a multiplayer extraction game.
PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Controls and connectivity
Game setup customization
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0
Players particularly like rearranging where weapons and ammunition sit on their virtual body, making reaching and reloading more comfortable.
Heist restart controls
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0
The missing quick-restart option in earlier builds frustrates stealth teams, forcing extra menus and loading after a failed approach.
Safehouse customization
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0
The hideout feels like a missed progression opportunity to players who want to buy decorations or upgrades between heists.