Compare Marathon vs PAYDAY: Aces High

Marathon

Marathon

Overall score 3.8 / 5

Based on 65 scored reviews

vs
PAYDAY: Aces High

PAYDAY: Aces High

Overall score 3.7 / 5

Based on 21 scored reviews

How we score

Scorata scores summarize analyzed review evidence on a 1–5 scale; they are not laboratory measurements or a simple average of customer star ratings. Feature scores summarize the reviews covering that feature. The overall score averages feature scores within each review, then combines review averages. When both expert and customer evidence are available, those two groups receive equal weight. Products can have different review coverage, so small score gaps do not establish a winner.

Recommendations prioritize important features for the category, with a score of at least 3.5, a gap of at least 0.25 points and at least two supporting reviews per product. Features with widely varying scores or broad connectivity contexts are excluded from recommendations. These safeguards do not establish statistical significance.

Quick verdict

What each product is best for

The review evidence points to a tradeoff: bug frequency and polish versus value for money and soundtrack quality. Choose according to which strengths matter more to you; the overall score alone does not settle that choice.

Choose Marathon for bug frequency and polish.

Choose PAYDAY: Aces High for value for money and soundtrack quality.

Why these recommendations?

Marathon

Where It Has the Edge

  • bug frequency is 5.0 vs 1.8. Major bugs appear uncommon during play. Serious issues are rare, with only a minor one-off NPC problem standing...
  • polish is 4.6 vs 2.0. The core shooter feels highly polished, from weapon handling to map presentation and audiovisual feedback. UI and onboarding...
  • faithfulness to franchise is 5.0 vs 4.5. The reboot carries meaningful connections to Bungie’s older Marathon games through lore, aesthetics, locations, and endgame references. Fans...

PAYDAY: Aces High

Where It Has the Edge

  • value for money is 4.7 vs 3.5. The $24.99 launch price looks appealing to players who will replay six heists with friends, especially with free...
  • soundtrack quality is 5.0 vs 4.3. Music shifts from quiet infiltration to driving combat tracks, building urgency and making a collapsing plan feel dramatic.
  • co-op experience is 4.8 vs 4.3. Coordinating break-ins, covering a teammate on the drill and scrambling to escape make co-op the standout attraction. Even...
Marathon 3.8 overall score
PAYDAY: Aces High 3.7 overall score

Compare features

Scores are out of 5. Missing scores mean missing review evidence, not a missing feature.

Scored on both products

Other features

World interactivity
Marathon
5.0

The strongest spaces are more than scenery: windows, doors, vertical routes, and interactive areas can change how a fight or infiltration plays out. Environmental choices have real tactical value.

PAYDAY: Aces High
1.7

The world looks convincing but often refuses natural VR actions such as smashing glass by hand, opening doors or moving bodies. Those limits repeatedly break immersion.

Bug frequency
Marathon
5.0

Major bugs appear uncommon during play. Serious issues are rare, with only a minor one-off NPC problem standing out among otherwise clean technical reports.

PAYDAY: Aces High
1.8

Some players report stuck movement, awkward gun interactions and unpredictable behavior. These issues are noticeable enough to detract from an otherwise fun heist.

Movement feel
Marathon
3.9

Movement is generally fluid and expressive, with sprinting, sliding, grapples, jumps, and shell abilities creating tactical routes. Heat limits, fall damage, and occasional mantling friction can make it feel less free-flowing than it first appears.

PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0

An early tester reports spontaneous movement and inconsistent sprinting, though they also acknowledge possible controller-tracking issues.

Polish
Marathon
4.6

The core shooter feels highly polished, from weapon handling to map presentation and audiovisual feedback. UI and onboarding roughness keep that polish from feeling equally strong outside matches.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

Rough interactions, bugs and unreliable AI make the release feel less finished than its core design deserves. The fundamental co-op loop remains appealing despite those problems.

Dialogue quality
Marathon
4.5

Faction dialogue helps sell the mystery and corporate personalities, with interactions described as meaningful, unnerving, and worth following. It works best for players already interested in the setting.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

Repeated briefing lines and mission instructions become tiresome during retries, particularly when players cannot mute them.

Animation quality
Marathon
4.3

Small animation details, including reload and movement touches, reinforce the snappy feel of play. The wider presentation also gives shells and weapons distinct animation work.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

Stilted guard and civilian movements were noticeable in an early build, though the underlying action still impressed.

Crash stability
Marathon
3.3

Crash behavior is mostly manageable but not flawless. A few mid-match crashes can occur, although rejoining softens the impact and some long sessions run without crashing at all.

PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0

A reviewer encountered several crashes in the hub area, an especially frustrating issue despite enjoying the actual jobs.

Accessibility options
Marathon
2.8

Accessibility is mixed: customizable subtitles and color options help, but there is no dedicated accessibility hub and audio-heavy play lacks strong visual sound-direction support. Hard-of-hearing players may be especially underserved.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Optional button-assisted gun actions and weapon placement controls help accommodate different reach and interaction preferences.

HUD clarity
Marathon
1.5

HUD readability has clear weaknesses, including very small text and objective markers that can be hard to spot. Those problems are especially costly when the game is already asking players to make quick decisions.

PAYDAY: Aces High
3.5

Wrist displays can deliver essential ammo, health and objective information efficiently, but objectives are harder to parse when firefights intensify.

Tutorial quality
Marathon
3.1

The tutorial covers the basic extraction loop, but it often leaves deeper systems to text prompts and trial-and-error. Its basic introduction works, yet the lack of guidance quickly becomes frustrating.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

The tutorial clearly teaches wrist hacking, guns, drilling and heist basics, letting newcomers to these mechanics enter their first robbery with confidence.

Stealth mechanics
Marathon
3.9

Stealth is a real playstyle rather than a novelty, especially with Rook and Assassin abilities. Sneaking, invisibility, noise control, and alternate routes can let careful players avoid or set up fights.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.2

Quiet infiltrations are possible and can be rewarding, yet detection frequently feels unpredictable and many jobs become unavoidable firefights. A minority appreciate stealth as a demanding skill challenge.

AI behavior
Marathon
3.3

Enemy AI is dangerous, aggressive, and often smart enough to flank, pressure, or expose players to rival squads. Balance has shifted through patches, and some players still find the bots either too punishing or less threatening than they should be.

PAYDAY: Aces High
1.7

Friendly and enemy AI attract some of the harshest criticism: teammates neglect tasks while enemies stand still or behave strangely. A few players find the bots serviceable for basic support, but reliability is a recurring issue.

Immersion
Marathon
4.5

The game can become deeply immersive once its lore, sound cues, world design, and tense extraction rhythm click together. Its unusual presentation helps players inhabit the role of a Runner rather than simply chase kills.

PAYDAY: Aces High
3.2

Physically sneaking, loading weapons and hauling loot can make players feel inside the job. Inert NPCs, missing body representation and constrained objects sometimes undermine that illusion.

Enemy variety
Marathon
3.3

Enemy variety is serviceable rather than a standout. Some players find enough variety to keep encounters from going stale, while others specifically call the bot roster limited.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

The police waves could use more distinct opponents; limited enemy types make repeat firefights feel familiar.

Difficulty balance
Marathon
2.8

Marathon is intentionally demanding, with lethal PvP, dangerous AI, and a steep skill curve. Hardcore players often admire that commitment, while casual and new players repeatedly find the difficulty intimidating or punishing.

PAYDAY: Aces High
3.9

Higher settings create worthwhile pressure and reward coordination for many players. Others dislike enemies gaining armor or health instead of more intelligent behavior.

Upgrade system
Marathon
3.5

Weapon mods, faction upgrades, cores, and implants can meaningfully reshape a loadout and keep progression interesting. The depth is rewarding once understood, though the surrounding menus can make upgrades harder to parse than necessary.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.5

Spending heist earnings on progressively better weapon tiers and equipment keeps the grind purposeful, even if some upgrades reuse the same weapon family.

Aiming precision
Marathon
4.0

Aiming benefits from Bungie’s familiar precision and strong weapon feedback, making accurate shooting feel satisfying. Some ADS-focused build effects matter less when fights end almost instantly.

PAYDAY: Aces High
3.0

Handling can feel accurate and rewarding, but critics report unpredictable spread even when a VR sight is lined up carefully. Responsiveness varies across builds and weapons.

Narrative quality
Marathon
4.0

The underlying story and mystery are compelling, but Marathon tells them indirectly through factions, lore entries, briefings, and environmental clues. That approach fascinates lore-minded players and leaves others wishing for a more direct campaign-style narrative.

PAYDAY: Aces High
3.0

The revenge setup stays out of the way of the action, which some appreciate, and the premise has personality. Players hoping for deeper characters or cinematic scenes may find it thin.

Mission variety
Marathon
2.5

Mission variety is a weak spot, especially early on. Repetitive fetch-style objectives can make the grind feel artificial even when later contracts become more interesting.

PAYDAY: Aces High
3.3

The individual settings and objectives offer some variety and can reward replaying them differently. Nevertheless, six initial heists and repeated structures leave certain players wanting more.

Core gameplay loop
Marathon
4.2

The drop-loot-extract loop produces tense, memorable runs and a strong one-more-match pull. Repetition can creep in when contracts stall or the available content starts feeling familiar.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Preparing a heist, adapting when the alarm sounds and getting out with the loot is a gripping, repeatable loop.

Weapon balance
Marathon
3.0

The arsenal is broadly viable, but not perfectly tuned. Sniper rifles in particular are described as slightly overtuned even while the overall weapon pool remains varied and useful.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.3

Damage, spread and enemy durability can make physically aimed shots feel unrewarding. Some enjoy the weapon differentiation, but bullet-sponge encounters recur in criticism.

Progression system
Marathon
3.6

Faction progression is one of the strongest long-term hooks, with reputation, upgrades, materials, and rewards giving failed runs some forward momentum. Seasonal resets and slow early progress are the main reservations.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.2

Cash, reputation, skills, upgraded weapons and masks give repeat robberies a tangible payoff. Several players like having reasons to improve rather than merely replaying the same job.

Content variety
Marathon
2.0

The available maps have distinct personalities, but the overall amount of launch content is a recurring concern. More maps and modes would help the strong individual spaces feel less limited over time.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.5

The launch roster covers several locations and tasks but is smaller than some hoped. Future free heists may help, though the starting scope remains a caveat.

Faithfulness to franchise
Marathon
5.0

The reboot carries meaningful connections to Bungie’s older Marathon games through lore, aesthetics, locations, and endgame references. Fans of the original universe get more continuity than the genre shift initially suggests.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.5

The familiar Payday cycle of planning, stealing, escaping and upgrading survives the jump to VR. Some returning fans miss the deeper systems and options of older entries.

Co-op experience
Marathon
4.3

Marathon is at its best with a coordinated group that communicates and combines shell abilities. Friends make risky gear choices and intense fights more manageable, while silent random squads can quickly unravel.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.8

Coordinating break-ins, covering a teammate on the drill and scrambling to escape make co-op the standout attraction. Even critical assessments say the game improves dramatically with human teammates.

Combat system
Marathon
4.5

Bungie-style gunplay is the clearest strength: weapons feel punchy, precise, and satisfying, and team fights can be exhilarating. The very short time-to-kill can also make some deaths feel abrupt or frustrating.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.0

Close-range gun battles can feel exhilarating, with manual reloads increasing the physical tension. Bullet spread, bullet-sponge enemies and relentless waves make the gunplay less satisfying for others.

Skill tree depth
Marathon
3.1

The faction trees create useful goals, but their structure is not always clear. Some players like having upgrades to chase, while others find the paths too loosely organized to make build decisions feel exciting.

PAYDAY: Aces High
3.0

Opinion differs sharply: one player calls the trees barebones for the franchise, while another loves the breadth of team buffs and loadout planning.

Pacing
Marathon
4.1

The pace swings between careful, slow movement and explosive, very short firefights. That contrast can create terrific tension, but it also makes the game feel abrupt or uneven for players expecting a faster run-and-gun shooter.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.0

Jobs become frenzied as wave after wave arrives, giving squads little time to relax while securing the objective.

Fun factor
Marathon
4.5

The game is highly enjoyable once it clicks, with gunplay and extraction highs repeatedly pulling players back. It is not instantly fun for everyone, and some players never get past the early friction.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.6

Botched plans turn into exhilarating, often funny shootouts, and most players found the action addictive. The enjoyment falls off when artificial intelligence or bugs interrupt the heist.

Graphics quality
Marathon
4.2

Graphics are widely praised for sharp detail, bold color, and strong presentation across platforms. The visual identity is a major draw even for players who are unsure about the extraction-shooter format.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.1

The visual response is divided: some call it excellent-looking on Quest or beautiful on PC, while others see flat textures and limited detail. PC generally offers a modest clarity advantage.

Haptic feedback integration
Marathon
5.0

DualSense haptics noticeably strengthen weapon feel on PS5. The implementation is singled out as stellar rather than merely present.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Controller vibration and tactile feedback make gunfire and safe manipulation feel more physical and rewarding.

Comfort and build

Puzzle design
Marathon
4.3

Cryo Archive’s vaults and endgame spaces add meaningful puzzle-solving to the extraction formula. The puzzle-heavy design is praised for depth, though some random elements can undermine a clean solution.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.5

Finding codes and working locks creates enjoyable heist tasks, but repeating combinations, forgiving safes and finicky dials can make the puzzle-solving feel superficial.

Mission design
Marathon
3.3

Contracts give each run a concrete purpose and feed faction progression, but several missions are vague, repetitive, or frustrating. The one-active-contract restriction is a frequent complaint because it can make failed runs feel wasted.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3

Heists offer different approaches, objectives and routes that encourage cooperation. Some encounters inevitably devolve into wave defense, and confusing instructions or repetition blunt that flexibility.

Level design
Marathon
4.4

Map design improves noticeably as the game opens up, with Outpost and Cryo Archive earning especially strong praise for verticality, secrets, and combat flow. The earliest maps are more divisive and can feel flat or repetitive.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Large compounds mix open and confined spaces, giving firefights different rhythms while making teamwork and navigation meaningful.

Sound design
Marathon
4.7

Sound design is a major strength, with footsteps, weapons, abilities, environmental hazards, and distant fights providing both atmosphere and tactical information. Good headphones materially improve situational awareness.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Gunfire, weapon feedback and the surrounding audio help sell hectic combat, with effects remaining distinctive during crowded encounters.

Map and navigation design
Marathon
2.2

Objectives are not always well signposted, and several maps can become hard to navigate under pressure. The problem ranges from tiny markers to layouts that make players lose time simply finding the next interaction point.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

Planning maps contain useful information, but one player found that busy missions reduced navigation to chasing icons rather than remembering the layout.

Ownership and support

Value for money
Marathon
3.5

The $39.99 entry price is considered reasonable by some players given the production quality, though the premium pass and live-service model complicate the value proposition. It is easier to justify for committed extraction-shooter fans than casual players.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.7

The $24.99 launch price looks appealing to players who will replay six heists with friends, especially with free future missions planned. A limited solo experience makes the value more conditional.

Live-service support
Marathon
4.3

Early support looks responsive, with balance patches, fixes, and community feedback moving quickly. Long-term confidence still depends on Bungie maintaining that pace and expanding the game enough to sustain its audience.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.0

Early fixes and scheduled additions encourage optimism about continued support, although launch problems still need concrete solutions.

Replay value
Marathon
4.4

The best runs create a powerful one-more-match pull, with several players staying hooked for dozens or even hundreds of hours. Long-term replayability depends on whether fresh content can keep repetition from overtaking the core loop.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3

Randomized loot and security, several difficulties, alternate approaches and unlocks invite repeat runs. The starting set of six heists still leaves some wondering about long-term variety.

Controls and connectivity

Character customization
Marathon
3.6

Shell skins and weapon cosmetics give players ways to personalize their look, but the reward quality is inconsistent. Recolors, repeated items, and paid cosmetics reduce the appeal of customization for some players.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.7

Masks, outfits and loadout choices let players shape their own criminal style. The available options grow with progression and are especially appreciated by returning players.

Controls responsiveness
Marathon
3.6

Shooting and movement controls are often described as crisp and responsive, but inventory swapping and a few control choices can feel cumbersome. Some players needed tweaking before the controls felt right.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3

Most praise the intuitive VR layout, particularly weapon grabs and wrist tools, though some report unwanted movement, awkward sprinting or inconsistent interactions.

Menu usability
Marathon
1.5

Menu navigation is often slower and more confusing than the shooting itself. The layout can become familiar with time, but familiarity does not fully solve the clutter and extra steps.

PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

An unusual right-stick settings shortcut and awkward navigation draw criticism from an early tester.

Voice acting
Marathon
5.0

Voice work is a presentation strength, especially in faction scenes and debriefs. The cast and performances add personality to material that could otherwise feel like dry lore delivery.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

The dialogue is delivered with notably strong performances, giving the lightweight revenge premise more character than expected.

Performance

Soundtrack quality
Marathon
4.3

The soundtrack ranges from understated and atmospheric to haunting and memorable. Music reinforces the uneasy sci-fi mood without overpowering the important positional audio.

PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Music shifts from quiet infiltration to driving combat tracks, building urgency and making a collapsing plan feel dramatic.

Performance optimization
Marathon
3.9

Performance is generally strong across consoles and a range of PCs, including older hardware. Most reports describe smooth play with few major technical problems, though isolated issues remain.

PAYDAY: Aces High
4.0

Quest performance is described as solid by some, with PC VR offering slightly smoother, sharper visuals. Preview builds also showed occasional flicker and uneven presentation.

Evidence available for one product

Other features

Achievement list quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.7

Masks, challenges and objectives tied to difficulty and stealth add useful goals beyond a single successful extraction.

Art direction
Marathon
4.4

The loud retro-futurist art direction is one of the game’s defining traits. It is often gorgeous, vibrant, and refreshingly distinctive, though the color and visual density can be overwhelming.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Atmosphere
Marathon
4.3

Tau Ceti IV has a distinctive uneasy atmosphere, mixing bright retro-futurism with abandoned spaces, corporate menace, and creeping dread. The contrast makes the world memorable even before combat starts.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Character roster
Marathon
4.2

The six main Runner shells plus Rook support noticeably different playstyles through movement, stealth, healing, defense, and utility. Their identities are useful and varied even when some archetypes feel familiar.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Class balance
Marathon
2.0

Shell balance needs tuning. Assassin can feel overpowered, while Recon can lag behind stronger defensive and offensive options.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Co-op communication
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Calling out guards, protecting the drill operator and coordinating an escape are central to success. Voice coordination gives these jobs their best tension and humor.

Co-op role balance
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.4

Human crews can divide shooting, hacking, drilling and hauling effectively, with loadouts encouraging specialization. Fixed character identities matter less than the perks and gadgets each person chooses.

Combat mode flexibility
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.5

Switching between stealth, direct assaults or hybrid approaches is a major part of the appeal. In practice, alarms often force players into the loud option.

Community features
Marathon
3.8

Proximity chat and lightweight communication can create memorable truces or help clear up intentions, but the wider culture remains heavily shoot-on-sight. Social cooperation is possible rather than encouraged.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Companion AI
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.4

Bot partners frequently fail to guard the drill, handle objectives or help carry loot, making solo play frustrating. Occasional healing or bag pickup helps, but does not fully replace a crew.

Competitive balance
Marathon
2.1

Competitive balance is most satisfying when teams and gear are evenly matched. Skill gaps, gear gaps, and uneven squad sizes can create lopsided fights that feel decided before tactics have a chance to matter.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Crafting system
Marathon
4.5

Build-crafting through mods and gear is flexible and satisfying, and the lack of extra crafting chores keeps the loop moving. The main tradeoff is that very short firefights can make some carefully built bonuses feel less important.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Economy and resource balance
Marathon
4.3

Materials and faction economies give players useful goals beyond simple kills, while barter rewards make salvage feel valuable. The better implementations keep resources circulating without completely removing the consequences of losing gear.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Emotional impact
Marathon
4.8

Successful extractions and close fights can produce unusually physical reactions—shaking hands, pounding hearts, relief, and triumph. The risk of losing gear gives victories and defeats more emotional weight than a routine shooter match.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Endgame content
Marathon
4.1

Cryo Archive is the standout endgame attraction, combining tougher AI, puzzles, high-value gear, bosses, and heavy PvP pressure. Its weekend-only access is repeatedly questioned despite the activity itself earning strong praise.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Environmental detail
Marathon
4.8

Maps reward close attention with environmental details that support both atmosphere and storytelling. The strongest spaces feel deliberately built rather than like generic combat arenas.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Exploration quality
Marathon
4.2

Exploration is rewarding when maps reveal vents, tunnels, locked rooms, hidden loot, and secrets. Some early areas become familiar too quickly, reducing the sense of discovery over time.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Frame rate stability
Marathon
4.9

Frame rates are consistently described as stable, including solid 60fps console performance and smooth higher-end PC results. Dropped-frame complaints are rare in the scored material.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Full-body avatar presence
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.5

Showing only floating hands rather than a complete body is a repeated immersion complaint, especially when trying to see an outfit or interact physically.

Gameplay mechanics
Marathon
3.9

The underlying systems are layered and often rewarding, especially once builds, faction goals, and extraction risks start working together. Some mechanics can clash with the very short time-to-kill.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Grind level
Marathon
2.7

The grind is substantial and central to Marathon’s identity. Some players enjoy faction progression and long-term goals, while others find repetitive quests and time demands exhausting.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Horror tension
Marathon
3.9

Tension is one of Marathon’s best tools: quiet looting can turn into a lethal encounter in seconds, and solo Rook runs can feel like survival horror. For some players that pressure becomes frustration rather than excitement.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Innovation
Marathon
3.7

Progression ideas, Cryo Archive, and the interaction between PvP and extraction systems show real cleverness. Still, the broader extraction-shooter direction can feel more trend-following than groundbreaking.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Inventory management
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

On-body holsters and a small pop-up item selector keep useful supplies accessible without constantly obstructing the view.

Learning curve
Marathon
2.3

The learning curve is steep and sometimes brutal, but many players say the game becomes far more rewarding once its systems click. That delayed payoff is a strength for committed players and a major obstacle for casual ones.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Load times
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

Returning to the hub and loading back into a heist after a failed stealth run makes retries needlessly slow.

Loot handling
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
3.3

Lifting bags adds stakes because carrying loot slows movement and restricts weapon use, making teamwork meaningful. Some hand interactions and bot bag handling are clumsy or inconsistent.

Loot system
Marathon
4.1

Loot creates the stakes that make extraction exciting, and modular gear can produce genuinely valuable finds. Losing a prized kit is thrilling when the system clicks and deeply frustrating when deaths or inventory friction feel unfair.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Lore depth
Marathon
3.9

Lore is unusually deep for a competitive shooter, with factions, AIs, codex entries, and ties to the original games creating a dense mystery. Players willing to read and connect clues get much more from the world than those who ignore it.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Matchmaking quality
Marathon
2.3

Matchmaking quality depends heavily on who fills the squad. Coordinated friends are preferred, while random teammates can make runs miserable even when the technical act of matchmaking works reliably.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Microtransaction impact
Marathon
3.5

Paid extras are mostly cosmetic and do not appear to create a serious pay-to-win problem. The bigger concern is the quality and pricing of the store and rewards pass rather than direct gameplay power.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Minigame quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.1

Safe dials, drill calibration and hacking are praised for giving VR players something physical to do during a robbery. Others find the tasks shallow, awkward or occasionally too easy.

Mission briefing repetition
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0

Unskippable, repeated spoken instructions become aggravating when teams retry missions often.

Monetization fairness
Marathon
3.5

Monetization earns mixed-to-negative reactions: expensive cosmetics and a weak rewards track draw criticism, but the lack of meaningful pay-to-win advantages is a clear positive. The base game is not gated by paid maps or abilities.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Objective clarity
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

A player struggles to work out an interaction during a heist, illustrating how objective steps can be unclear amid the action.

Onboarding experience
Marathon
2.2

Onboarding is one of the biggest barriers. Dense menus, limited guidance, unclear objectives, and unfamiliar extraction systems can make the first several hours feel much harder than the later game.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Online stability
Marathon
5.0

Connections are generally stable, with few disconnect-style problems surfacing during long sessions. Online reliability is much less troublesome than the game’s UI or balance.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Originality
Marathon
4.3

Marathon feels most original in its audiovisual identity, corporate sci-fi setting, and the way it reshapes extraction-shooter conventions. Some class and genre elements are familiar enough to keep it from feeling wholly new.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Overall quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3

A compelling VR adaptation whose cooperative thrills outweigh its rough spots for many. Less enthusiastic players point to the thin AI, inconsistent stealth and limited environmental freedom.

Platforming precision
Marathon
2.0

Jumping and climbing can feel smooth when the geometry cooperates, but mantling is inconsistent enough to cause failures at bad moments. Ledge grabs are the clearest point of frustration.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Sandbox freedom
Marathon
4.5

Players can often choose how much danger to accept, from quietly looting and extracting to chasing tougher events or fights. That flexibility is a major part of the appeal for players who dislike being forced into constant combat.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Seasonal content quality
Marathon
4.5

Season 1’s early content is described as a fun addition, with extra rewards and activities fitting naturally into normal play. The longer-term seasonal cadence still has more to prove.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Social features
Marathon
3.9

Friends, proximity chat, and coordinated squads can produce some of the game’s best moments. Solo-focused players also point out that finding a dependable group is harder than it should be.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Solo play quality
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.8

Solo jobs lose the communication and division of labor that make heists shine, and AI teammates often struggle to compensate. Easier settings can be manageable, but most recommend bringing friends.

Spawn placement
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0

Cops sometimes appear abruptly in view, distracting from combat and breaking the illusion of a believable heist.

Visual effects quality
Marathon
4.5

Shield breaks and explosive hits provide satisfying visual feedback during combat. Those effects help gunfights feel punchy without needing elaborate spectacle.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
VR heist interactions
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Wrist-based hacking, drill controls, safe dials and on-body equipment make heists feel purpose-built for a headset. These tactile details are a consistent highlight.

VR implementation
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3

Manual reloads, wrist hacking, safe manipulation and physically carrying loot make this more immediate than traditional Payday. Some interactions remain oddly restricted and limit the full VR fantasy.

VR weapon handling
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.1

Manually manipulating guns and reloading is often satisfying and tactile. Early builds and some launch impressions also describe awkward interactions, imprecise spread or simplified handling.

Weapon variety
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3

Rifles, pistols, shotguns, SMGs and multiple tiers offer a useful arsenal for different roles. Some wish there were more genuinely distinct weapons rather than upgrades of the same base models.

Writing quality
Marathon
4.5

Faction introductions and story moments benefit from sharp, personality-driven writing. The strongest dialogue and briefings make the corporations and AIs feel distinctive rather than like generic quest dispensers.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet

Performance

Audio settings
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0

The inability to adjust voice-chat volume is a specific missing control that can make multiplayer audio less flexible.

Ownership and support

Battle pass value
Marathon
2.4

The first battle or rewards pass is a weak point, with recolors, duplicate items, and underwhelming cosmetics drawing criticism. Its non-expiring, low-pressure structure is one of the few positives.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Cross-play support
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Cross-platform play makes it easier for players on supported VR systems to join the same heist with friends.

DLC value
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

The promise of free future heists is repeatedly welcomed because it can expand the mission pool without splitting the player base behind paid maps.

Platform-specific feature support
Marathon
4.5

PS5-specific features are used well, especially the strong DualSense haptics and PS5 Pro image treatment. These additions reinforce the already strong presentation rather than changing the core game.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Server reliability
Marathon
4.0

Servers held up well during play, with no major reliability problems standing out. The bigger uncertainty is long-term population and support rather than immediate server stability.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet

Comfort and build

Boss design
Marathon
4.0

Cryo Archive gives boss encounters real endgame weight, with difficult fights and a final encounter that can feel worth the preparation. Bosses are most effective when combined with the map’s PvP and puzzle pressure.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Build variety and synergy
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.6

Custom loadouts, gadgets and team-oriented perks give crews tactical choices and let members specialize. This flexibility adds purpose to preparation and repeat heists.

Control input comfort
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0

Safe dialing can require uncomfortable wrist twisting, particularly when trying to complete the combination under pressure.

Enemy design
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.5

Criticism centers on bullet-spongy foes and difficulty that scales durability rather than tactical intelligence.

Multiplayer design
Marathon
3.9

Multiplayer is aggressively PvP-focused, with trios, solo play, and emerging duo options producing very different experiences. Squad play can be excellent, while solo and mismatched team sizes expose some of the game’s harshest tradeoffs.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
Quest design
Marathon
3.3

Questing gives the extraction loop direction and steady progression, yet the structure can be restrictive and grindy. Fetch-style objectives, poor signposting, and one-at-a-time progression are common pain points.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
User interface design
Marathon
1.8

The interface is the most consistent criticism. Menus, inventory icons, loot management, and information density are stylish but frequently described as cluttered, confusing, or unnecessarily hard to use.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet
VR comfort settings
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
4.3

Standard comfort controls, holster placements and seated-friendly options make the game adaptable. Some additional fine-tuning would still be welcome.

World-building
Marathon
4.7

Corporate factions, environmental storytelling, and sci-fi lore give Tau Ceti IV a strong sense of place. The world-building is often praised as unusually rich for a multiplayer extraction game.

PAYDAY: Aces HighNo score yet

Controls and connectivity

Game setup customization
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
5.0

Players particularly like rearranging where weapons and ammunition sit on their virtual body, making reaching and reloading more comfortable.

Heist restart controls
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
1.0

The missing quick-restart option in earlier builds frustrates stealth teams, forcing extra menus and loading after a failed approach.

Safehouse customization
MarathonNo score yet
PAYDAY: Aces High
2.0

The hideout feels like a missed progression opportunity to players who want to buy decorations or upgrades between heists.

Other Top Video Games to Consider

#1 Well Dweller
4.7

Best for fluid traversal, rewarding exploration, striking art, and forgiving quality-of-life features. Skip it if you want deep combat, radical genre innovation, or consistently demanding bosses.

Pros: difficulty balance, boss design

Cons: innovation, sandbox freedom

#2 Hades II
4.5

Best for superb combat, inventive builds, and richly voiced characters. Skip it if repeated runs, resource gathering, or visually busy battles outweigh the appeal of steady progress.

Pros: overall quality, combat system

Cons: pacing, grind level

#3 Valheim
4.5

Good if you want a beautiful, demanding survival sandbox built around exploration, building, progression, and memorable co-op. Skip it if long resource runs, harsh death recovery, and deliberate pacing sound...

Pros: town-building system, exploration quality

Cons: grind level, fast travel convenience

#4 Grand Theft Auto VI
4.5

Leonida is a breathtakingly alive crime sandbox with memorable protagonists, spectacular heists, and extraordinary detail. The tradeoff is a 30 fps ceiling, occasional control awkwardness, and some progression friction.

Pros: immersion, graphics quality

Cons: grind level, controls responsiveness