#1
Overall: 3.8/5
Revisiting is strongly encouraged by enthusiasts, and the admired Blu-ray editions make an especially rewarding return through their presentation and supplements.
Pros: production design, acting performance
Cons: editing quality, story quality
#2
Overall: 3.5/5
Longtime Scrooge fans can appreciate the new cast and Gothic treatment, though familiarity also makes the thin reinvention conspicuous.
Pros: faithfulness to source material, supporting cast performance
Cons: lead performance, originality