#1
Overall: 3.7/5
His reimagining layers contemporary fear and moral ambiguity onto the revenge premise. Dread and manipulation are major strengths, although the expansion is divisive.
Pros: acting performance, villain quality
Cons: season length, season pacing
#2
Overall: 2.6/5
Antosca’s screenplay draws mostly negative reactions for weak motivation, unanswered questions, overstuffed shock tactics, and tonal misfires. A few viewers enjoy the slow-burn construction, but the writing is a frequent...
Pros: acting performance, production design
Cons: entertainment value, genre satisfaction