Scorata scores summarize analyzed review evidence on a 1–5 scale; they are not laboratory measurements or a simple average of customer star ratings. Feature scores summarize the reviews covering that feature. The overall score averages feature scores within each review, then combines review averages. When both expert and customer evidence are available, those two groups receive equal weight. Products can have different review coverage, so small score gaps do not establish a winner.
Recommendations prioritize important features for the category, with a score of at least 3.5, a gap of at least 0.25 points and at least two supporting reviews per product. Features with widely varying scores or broad connectivity contexts are excluded from recommendations. These safeguards do not establish statistical significance.
Quick verdict
What each product is best for
The review evidence points to a tradeoff: Onboard tool storage and Carpet — Medium-Pile Pickup versus Maneuverability and Handling and Hose length. Choose according to which strengths matter more to you; the overall score alone does not settle that choice.
Choose Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum for Onboard tool storage and Carpet — Medium-Pile Pickup.
Choose Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum for Maneuverability and Handling and Hose length.
Why these recommendations?
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
Where It Has the Edge
Onboard tool storage is 4.5 vs 3.3. Onboard tool storage was praised as convenient and nicely designed.
Carpet — Medium-Pile Pickup is 4.0 vs 3.0. On ordinary fitted carpet, reviewers described pickup as pretty good in short demonstrations.
Controls and UI is 4.4 vs 3.5. Controls were consistently described as simple, especially the foot-style power control and basic operation.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
Where It Has the Edge
Maneuverability and Handling is 3.7 vs 2.8. Handling was usually positive on the newer models, but the CNET Dash review found it less maneuverable than...
Hose length is 3.7 vs 3.1. Hose length was decent on newer owner reviews, but CNET considered the Dash hose ungenerous against a named...
Scores are out of 5. Missing scores mean missing review evidence, not a missing feature.
Scored on both products
Other features
Ease of use
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.9
Ease of use was split: simple controls and setup earned praise, but a lab review found the minimalist design less user-friendly in practice.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.3
Ease of use was generally good once assembled, with simple operation and disassembly, though filter condition affected cleaning performance.
Floorhead Seal on Hard Floors
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
1.8
Hard-floor seal performance was weak in one test, where debris kicked backward from under the head.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.0
One Rewind review praised the bare-floor seal, saying it helped pick up debris that might normally scatter.
Emptying and Mess Control
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.6
Emptying was consistently praised as simple, quick, and easy through the release-button canister design.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.8
Emptying and mess control were mixed: one-touch/removable bins helped, but accidental bin release, grimy handling, and trash-can positioning were concerns.
Area Rug Handling
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
5.0
Area-rug performance was praised strongly in the dedicated rug test.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.4
Area-rug handling was mixed: reviewers saw dirt pickup, but also noted hard pushing and annoying height-setting compromises.
Bin and Bag
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.4
Reviewers liked the dust bin size and easy-empty canister, describing it as sizable, big, and slow to fill.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.9
The bin was praised for capacity/removability in some reviews, but several reviewers disliked accidental release, grimy handling, or awkward reinstallation.
Carpet — High-Pile Pickup
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.5
High-pile and thick-carpet feedback was notably better, with one lab test scoring above average and another reviewer praising deep carpet pickup.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
High-pile evidence was limited and only moderately positive, mostly pet-hair pickup rather than broad debris testing.
Cord length
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.3
Cord length received positive comments from reviewers who called it decently long or nice and long.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
Cord length evidence was split, with CNET calling 25 feet plenty but the detailed newer-model review calling the cord too short.
Onboard tool storage
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.5
Onboard tool storage was praised as convenient and nicely designed.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.3
Onboard storage was convenient in the roundup, but reviewers criticized an unused post, missing accessory, and tool-storage oddities.
Hair‑Wrap / Tangle Resistance
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.0
Hair-wrap resistance was mixed, with one reviewer impressed by a clean brush roll and other testing finding tangles with long hair.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
1.8
Hair-wrap/tangle resistance was poor in CNET's human-hair test, where hair tangled and wrapped around the rollerbrush.
Carpet — Medium-Pile Pickup
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.0
On ordinary fitted carpet, reviewers described pickup as pretty good in short demonstrations.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
Medium-pile performance was context-dependent, ranging from CNET's weak pickup to newer-model reviewers who found carpet contact finicky but workable.
Clogging and debris prevention
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.0
Large-debris handling was a weakness in tougher tests, where Cheerios or rice were pushed or plowed instead of cleanly collected.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
Clogging/debris prevention evidence was split: one review praised multi-cyclonic clog reduction, while CNET found tool clogging and brush-well jams.
Hard Floor — Large Debris Intake
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
1.7
Hard-floor large-debris intake was weak in multiple tests, with snowplowing and scattered debris noted.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.7
Large-debris hard-floor pickup was mixed, with positive claims about fewer passes but CNET's hard-floor Cheerios result was poor.
Maneuverability and Handling
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.8
Handling was one of the most mixed areas: the vacuum is light, but several reviewers disliked the non-swivel head and carpet resistance.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.7
Handling was usually positive on the newer models, but the CNET Dash review found it less maneuverable than comparable vacuums.
Cord management
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.2
Cord management received a positive mention for the wrap hooks keeping the cord tidy.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.5
Cord management varied by variant: the non-rewind cord fought the reviewer during wrapping, while the Rewind's retracting cord was praised.
Suitability for heavy-duty use
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.5
Reviewers framed it as an entry-level or simple-task vacuum rather than a serious long-term heavy-duty cleaner.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.3
Heavy-duty suitability was limited: the Rewind was framed for heavier cleaning, but CNET found jam-clearing could create extra work.
Carpet — Low-Pile Pickup
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.8
Low-pile or standard carpet results ranged from poor lab performance to very strong owner demonstrations, making this a mixed attribute.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.1
Low-pile pickup split by model/review: CNET measured poor sand pickup, while the newer model did excellently on low-pile commercial carpet.
Pet-Ready Features
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.3
Pet-readiness was divided: one lab-style review found pet hair performance poor, while a family-use review said regular vacuuming solved their cat-hair problems.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.0
Pet-oriented tools and hair pickup earned praise in positive reviews, but the included pet/turbo accessories were not consistently strong across all evidence.
Overall opinion
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.2
Overall opinion was split between strong budget praise from video reviewers and a much harsher lab review that placed it near the bottom.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.6
Overall opinion was highly mixed: several reviewers liked the newer models at $100, while CNET strongly rejected the older Dash evidence.
Hose length
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.1
Reach was mixed: one reviewer liked the hose for counter-height cleaning, while others wished the wand or hose were longer.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.7
Hose length was decent on newer owner reviews, but CNET considered the Dash hose ungenerous against a named Eureka comparison.
Filtration / Dust Containment
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.1
Dust containment evidence conflicted, with one review criticizing the unsealed system while another found it unlikely to worsen sensitivity issues.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.6
Filtration drew praise in roundup-style coverage and from one owner, but the detailed review criticized it as an unsealed budget system with dust getting through.
Tool-change simplicity
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.5
The wand and hose changeover drew a caveat because one reviewer warned users not to forget reconnecting the tube properly.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.0
Tool changes and fittings were a recurring weak spot, with reviewers criticizing awkward attachment installation and proprietary/custom hose fittings.
Versatility
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.5
One review found some versatility through the wand for furniture and ceilings, but only in a qualified way.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.0
Versatility was a strength for floor types and above-floor use, but bare-floor safety and custom tools limited the otherwise broad use case.
Hard Floor — Fine Dust Pickup
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.5
Hard-floor fine debris results were highly inconsistent but mostly negative, with repeated reports of sand or grit being kicked back or scattered.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
Hard-floor fine-dust evidence was mixed: CNET found weak fine-particle performance, while first-impression demos saw fine dust pickup on carpet and bare-floor demos looked better.
Accessories and Tools
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.5
Tool feedback was mixed: reviewers liked having a wand or basic tool set at the price, but another called the included attachments very basic.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.1
Accessories were useful in some reviews, but the tool package was inconsistent, with complaints about a stubby wand, custom fitting, missing tools, and a disappointing turbo tool.
Hair Pickup — Carpets
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.0
Carpet hair pickup was split, ranging from untouched pet hair in lab testing to several reviewers reporting easy cat-hair pickup.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.8
Carpet hair pickup was generally favorable in newer reviews, but CNET found the older Dash comparatively weak despite a 92 percent pet-hair result.
Maintenance requirements
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.3
Maintenance feedback was mixed, with one review frustrated by a non-removable brush roll and another liking how simple filter access was.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.1
Maintenance requirements were mixed: filters and savings were manageable, but brush access, filter washing, and jam-clearing could be tedious.
Upholstery / Above-Floor Pickup
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.0
Above-floor cleaning was mixed, with one reviewer finding the dusting tool decent and another finding upholstery cleaning ineffective.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.9
Upholstery and above-floor pickup were inconsistent: CNET's turbo tool clogged with pet hair, while newer reviews found the turbo tool acceptable or powerful.
Weight
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.1
The vacuum was broadly praised as lightweight, although two reviews noted that carpet suction or awkward handling can make it feel heavier in use.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.1
Weight evidence was mostly positive: the vacuum was described as light or easy to carry, though the newer model traded some weight for sturdier build.
Under-Furniture Pickup
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.0
Under-furniture cleaning was criticized because the vacuum was not good at getting under surfaces such as beds.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.0
Under-furniture cleaning was a weakness because the bulkier cyclone assembly prevented reaching under low furniture.
Ownership and support
Assembly and Setup
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
5.0
One owner-style review said assembly and setup were very easy.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.0
Assembly was a clear pain point in the unboxing review, with the handle and screws described as surprisingly difficult.
Price and Value
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.3
Value depended heavily on price: some called it one of the best cheap uprights, while others said full list price made it less compelling.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
Value depended heavily on price: reviewers liked it around $100, but criticized it at $119-$130 and strongly rejected the older Dash's value.
Performance
Noise level
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
5.0
Only one reviewer evaluated noise directly and praised the vacuum as quieter than other vacuums they had used.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.1
Noise impressions were mixed: one reviewer said the vacuum was not very loud, while another called the turbo brush loud and rattly and the Rewind louder than a cordless unit.
Edge and Baseboard Cleaning (Hard Floors)
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.7
Edge cleaning varied sharply, with budget testing saying it missed edges and one demonstration saying it cleaned right to the edge.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.2
Only one review supplied opinionated edge-cleaning evidence, and it was positive about reducing dirt hiding near walls and corners.
One reviewer praised the included second filter as a nice ownership touch.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.7
Ownership costs look moderate: some evidence praised fewer filter replacements, but the detailed review still expects washing and periodic filter replacement.
Comparative performance
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
3.2
In one standardized pickup test it was acceptable but clearly not among the best performers.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.0
Comparative performance evidence diverged sharply, with CNET's Dash test performing poorly and the detailed reviewer calling the newer model a major Dirt Devil improvement.
Suction and Airflow
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.3
Reviewers generally found the AirSpeed strong for its size and price, with measured airflow and repeated praise for suction, though one budget roundup still placed it below pricier uprights.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.4
Reviewers most often praised suction and airflow, especially on the newer Multi-Surface Total Pet, though that strength did not rescue every hard-floor or tool scenario.
Controls and connectivity
Controls and UI
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.4
Controls were consistently described as simple, especially the foot-style power control and basic operation.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.5
Controls were generally simple and accessible, but height adjustment and release mechanisms could be awkward or inconvenient.
Comfort and build
Floorhead design
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.7
The floorhead drew mixed reactions: the brush roll impressed at the price, but the no-height-adjustment/basic design caused snowplowing and poor debris behavior.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.2
The floorhead earned praise for stiff bristles and a felt gasket, but reviewers also criticized carpet-contact issues and the lack of brushroll shutoff.
Overall durability/longevity
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.0
Durability impressions ranged from plasticky but maybe serviceable for a few years to one family calling it tried-and-true after a year.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
3.5
The detailed reviewer saw better construction and motor feel than older Dirt Devils, but still considered longevity below the equivalent Bissell.
Build quality and durability
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
4.0
Build quality was polarized, with one review calling it plasticky and others saying it felt high quality or did not feel cheap.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
4.3
The newer model's build quality received strong praise for sturdiness, thicker plastic, and feeling less cheap than prior Dirt Devils.
Low-profile design
Eureka Airspeed Ultra-Lightweight Vacuum
2.0
The low-profile design was weak because one review said it was not good for cleaning under surfaces.
Dirt Devil Multi-Surface Upright Vacuum
2.0
Low-profile reach was poor because the cyclone assembly prevented getting under low furniture.
Cyclone performance was improved versus older Dirt Devils in some owner evidence, but the detailed review still called the cyclone ineffective under dust load.
Best for exceptional hard-floor stain removal, self-cleaning, powered handling, and rare steam-plus-hot-water versatility. Skip it if you need a lightweight, compact, budget-friendly cleaner or serious carpet cleaning.
Choose the Eureka OmniVerse for strong value, versatile floor and above-floor cleaning, pet pickup, and under-furniture reach. Skip it if you want premium-feeling tool changes, a larger bin, or the...
Choose the Shark Stratos for powerful upright cleaning, sealed HEPA filtration, Lift-Away versatility, and strong hard-floor or low-pile carpet pickup. Skip it if you need a lightweight vacuum or mainly...
Choose the Shark PowerDetect for strong whole-home suction, pet hair pickup, smart modes and Lift-Away reach. Skip it if you need a lightweight, quiet vacuum with a long hose or...
Pros: Hard Floor — Fine Dust Pickup, Overall opinion