Compare Apple Watch SE 3 vs Garmin Lily 2 Active

GPS accuracy was mostly praised for everyday workouts, though reviewers noted single-band GPS can wander in dense urban or more challenging environments.

GPS accuracy is one of the strongest themes, with reviewers repeatedly finding quick locks, solid routes, and close agreement with other devices.

Heart-rate tracking drew strong praise across testing, with reviewers saying it aligned well with comparison devices and remained usable even in harder workouts.

Heart-rate accuracy is consistently praised, with reviewers noting only minor delays or brief misses during harder efforts.

Sleep tracking was generally useful and often accurate enough, though several reviewers felt Apple’s Sleep Score was simpler than competing systems.

Sleep tracking earns strong marks overall, especially for wake/sleep timing and presentation, though one reviewer wanted more refinement in stages.

Fitness tracking accuracy was a clear strength, with reviewers reporting reliable workout, activity, and comparison-test results for the price.

Fitness tracking accuracy is a major strength, with multiple reviewers finding pace, distance, and overall workout data accurate.

Recovery-related evidence was limited, but one fitness-focused review valued training-load tracking as a way to monitor workout volume over time.

Recovery and readiness tools are praised for helping shape training decisions and fine-tune workouts.

Workout Buddy and coaching features were appreciated as helpful motivation, though reviewers often described them as basic, repetitive, or hit-or-miss.

Coaching features are well received, with reviewers praising Garmin Coach, adaptive plans, and guided structured workouts.

Workout variety was viewed very positively, with reviewers noting broad sport profiles and nearly the same workout options as pricier Apple Watches.

Workout variety is broadly praised because the Active adds many sports, workout modes, and training tools for a compact Lily watch.

Blood oxygen tracking was consistently treated as a missing premium health feature, with reviewers noting it remains reserved for higher-end Apple Watches.

One reviewer was very positive about Pulse Ox readings, saying the watch routinely matched their normal SpO2 range.

Wellness insights were considered helpful for beginners or casual users, especially Sleep Score, sleep apnea alerts, and the Vitals-style health context.

Wellness insights are a standout, especially Body Battery, women’s health context, sleep, stress, and overall body-awareness feedback.

Reviewers described the core health basics as adequate or mostly complete, especially heart-rate alerts and general tracking, while noting that advanced sensors remain absent.

One review gives the broader health-tracking package a very strong assessment, describing fitness tracking as excellent within Garmin’s health ecosystem.

Comfort was a consistent strength, especially for sleep, smaller wrists, and unobtrusive daily wear.

Comfort is one of the most consistent strengths, with reviewers saying the small, light watch is easy to forget on the wrist.

Materials quality evidence was limited but positive, centered on the aluminum case, rounded body, and premium-looking construction.

Materials quality is criticized by one reviewer for relying on cheaper materials.

Fit evidence was limited and mixed, with one reviewer saying the older body did not sit as flush as the Series 11.

Fit is excellent for the intended user, especially people who want a small watch that sits comfortably on smaller wrists.

Style and design were the main aesthetic tradeoff: reviewers liked the familiar Apple Watch look but repeatedly called it dated or bezel-heavy.

Style and design are major strengths, with reviewers repeatedly praising the fashionable, subtle, non-smartwatch look.

Build quality was considered solid for the price, with reviewers calling it well made and modern enough despite the older design.

Build quality draws criticism from one reviewer who dislikes the cheaper-material feel.

Durability was mixed: stronger Ion-X glass drew praise, but some reviewers noted weaker dust/scratch protection or actual scratching.

Durability is a concern for one reviewer, who connects the aluminum casing to easier scratching and reduced durability.

Band quality evidence was limited but very positive, with praise for easily replaceable Apple Watch bands.

Band quality is praised for comfort, quick-release swapping, and easy removal.

Battery life was the main practical compromise, ranging from excellent in some tests to daily-charge frustration in others.

Battery life is strongly praised, often beating or matching expectations and lasting around a week or more in real use.

Charging convenience was mixed because faster top-ups help, but sleep tracking still forces many users into a daily charging routine.

Charging convenience improves because the watch uses the standard Garmin cable rather than the older Lily clip style.

Display quality was a major upgrade thanks to always-on functionality, though reviewers still noted smaller bezels and lower specs than Series models.

Display quality is divisive: reviewers like the contrast and hidden-display style, but some dislike the monochrome screen or limited visual richness.

Outdoor visibility was generally serviceable, but direct sunlight remained a repeated display limitation.

Outdoor visibility is mostly strong in sunlight, although one reviewer found bright outdoor conditions could make it harder to read.

Brightness was usually adequate and sometimes praised, but reviewers acknowledged it is below the brighter Series and Ultra screens.

Brightness is generally acceptable, with one reviewer noting easy viewing, while another says the screen itself is not ultra-bright.

Reliability evidence was limited but positive, with one reviewer concluding the SE 3 has what most users need.

Reliability is positive in one review, with the reviewer saying GPS remained spot-on and did not drop.

Value for money was the strongest consensus attribute, with reviewers repeatedly calling the SE 3 a standout bargain or best-value Apple Watch.

Value is mixed-to-positive: many reviewers think the upgrades justify the price, while a few criticize the cost versus fuller smartwatches.

Touchscreen responsiveness had limited but very positive evidence, with PCMag saying the watch responded promptly and consistently.

Touchscreen responsiveness is split, with one reviewer finding it very sensitive and simple, while another calls the controls finicky.

watchOS experience received very strong marks for polish, smoothness, and making the SE 3 feel similar to pricier Apple Watches.

The operating experience may feel unusual to traditional Garmin users, but the reviewer says the approach makes sense for this type of watch.

The companion app setup drew a mixed note because managing Watch, Health, and Fitness across multiple iPhone apps can feel tedious.

The companion app is useful for setup, coaching, and deeper tracking, with one reviewer preferring it for faster, clearer health logging.

Navigation evidence was limited but positive, with offline Apple Maps presented as helpful when away from the phone.

Mapping and navigation are mixed-to-weak: GPS mapping after workouts works, but reviewers note no detailed map display and no hiking profile.

Watch faces were viewed positively, especially the always-on versions and Apple’s high-quality built-in choices.

Watch face quality is mixed, with one reviewer liking the selection and another finding the options very limiting.

Reviewers generally agreed the SE 3 delivers the core Apple Watch experience, making it feel much less like a compromised budget model.

Smartwatch features are mixed: some reviewers see a well-rounded compact device, while one finds the smart-feature set limited for the price.

Music controls and speaker/media features were useful additions, though reviewers were split on how often they would actually use playback from the watch speaker.

Music controls work well for controlling phone playback from the wrist.

Button and gesture controls were widely praised, especially Double Tap, Wrist Flick, the Digital Crown, and side-button shortcuts.

Button controls are a unanimous strength because they make workouts and navigation much easier than touch-only Lily models.

Apple Pay was positively mentioned as part of the compelling smartwatch feature set and deep Apple ecosystem integration.

Garmin Pay is considered useful and easy to set up, though one reviewer notes its value drops if a phone is still needed for music.

Software smoothness was one of the most consistent strengths, with reviewers praising the S10 chip for snappy menus, fast apps, and fluid navigation.

Software smoothness is positive, with reviewers noting smooth syncing and smooth navigation between widgets.

Pairing/setup evidence was limited but positive, with one review calling setup quick and easy.

Pairing reliability is praised across sensor use, with reviewers noting easy sensor connections and appreciation for expanded external sensor support.

Third-party app support was praised for extending the native experience, with reviewers highlighting Apple’s App Store depth and useful fitness apps.

Third-party app support is positive, especially syncing workout data outward and broadcasting heart rate to other devices.

Customization was useful through watch faces, workout views, and settings, but limited by the lack of third-party watch faces.

Customization is mixed-to-good: notifications and data views have useful controls, but watch-face flexibility is more limited than other Garmins.

Notification handling was a major everyday strength, with reviewers praising call, text, and response convenience from the wrist.

Smartphone notifications are considered helpful for quickly checking messages during outdoor activity.

The app ecosystem was one of the SE 3’s strongest advantages, repeatedly described as unmatched or far richer than competing budget watches.

The app ecosystem is praised as comprehensive for wellness data and long-term health interpretation.

Call handling was rated highly where tested, especially voice isolation and gesture-based call management.

Call handling is useful for glancing at calls on the wrist without pulling out a phone.

Menu navigation evidence was limited but positive, with one reviewer describing the basic home-screen and control flow as simple.

Menu navigation is viewed positively, with one reviewer describing swiping and app opening as smooth.

The user interface was praised as easy, cohesive, and fluid, with gestures and Smart Stack improving quick interactions.

The user interface is praised as simple to learn and easy to swipe through.

Cross-platform compatibility was a clear limitation because the SE 3 remains an iPhone-only smartwatch.

Cross-platform compatibility is mixed because Android users get quick replies while iPhone users cannot reply from the watch.

ECG was the most repeated missing health feature, often framed as the main reason some higher-risk buyers might step up to the Series line.

ECG is a clear limitation: a reviewer explicitly wished Garmin had included the hardware for ECG-related features.

Safety features were strongly praised, especially fall detection, crash detection, emergency features, and real family anecdotes.

Safety features are praised as reassuring for solo runs and emergency-contact situations.

Auto-detection was useful but not flawless; reviewers found it adequate for walks and workouts, while one later review said it still lagged rivals.

Cellular connectivity was viewed as a useful option, with 5G improving coverage, efficiency, and phone-free use for calls, messages, and downloads.

Bluetooth connectivity is viewed positively because the watch pairs easily with phones and other devices.

Onboard music storage is a repeated downside because the watch lacks local music even though it now has built-in GPS.

On-device Siri was broadly seen as a useful upgrade, making commands faster and more practical for workouts, timers, weather, and health questions.

Calorie tracking appeared as part of the useful core fitness toolkit, with one test finding calorie and distance figures matched a comparison watch exactly.

Step counting is described as close but slightly high, with limitations when the arm is not moving normally.

Stress tracking is viewed as a useful interpretive metric, especially because it helps explain Body Battery changes.

Charging speed improved substantially over the SE 2 and was usually praised, even when still slower than pricier Apple Watches.

Size options were viewed positively for offering 40mm and 44mm choices, especially for smaller wrists.

Water resistance was considered adequate for common needs, with several reviewers accepting the 50m/swimproof rating.