Overall score
3.9 / 5
Based on 20 scored reviews
vs
×
Overall score
3.8 / 5
Based on 64 scored reviews
How we score Scorata scores summarize analyzed review evidence on a 1–5 scale; they are not laboratory measurements or a simple average of customer star ratings. Feature scores summarize the reviews covering that feature. The overall score averages feature scores within each review, then combines review averages. When both expert and customer evidence are available, those two groups receive equal weight. Products can have different review coverage, so small score gaps do not establish a winner.
Recommendations prioritize important features for the category, with a score of at least 3.5, a gap of at least 0.25 points and at least two supporting reviews per product. Features with widely varying scores or broad connectivity contexts are excluded from recommendations. These safeguards do not establish statistical significance.
Compare features
Quick verdict
What each product is best for
The review evidence points to a tradeoff: originality and character development versus combat system and controls responsiveness. Choose according to which strengths matter more to you; the overall score alone does not settle that choice.
Choose South of Midnight for originality and character development.
Choose Orbitals for combat system and controls responsiveness.
Why these recommendations?
South of Midnight
Where It Has the Edge
originality is 4.7 vs 2.7. Originality was praised for its fresh Southern Gothic setting, visual identity, and rarely explored cultural focus. character development is 4.6 vs 3.3. Character development was praised for making characters feel real and emotionally grounded. environmental detail is 4.8 vs 3.8. Environmental detail was repeatedly praised for rich, meticulous spaces, lighting, clutter, and sense of place.
Orbitals
Where It Has the Edge
combat system is 3.9 vs 2.7. Ship combat adds welcome urgency but can become chaotic or uncomfortable, particularly when missiles and hazards crowd the... controls responsiveness is 4.1 vs 3.0. Movement and tool use are widely considered responsive and intuitive, helping failures feel tied to coordination rather than... core gameplay loop is 3.8 vs 3.0. Moment-to-moment play is lively and cooperative, although some critics find its repeated tool interactions less ambitious than its...
South of Midnight
3.9 overall score
Orbitals
3.8 overall score
Compare features
Scores are out of 5. Missing scores mean missing review evidence, not a missing feature.
Find a feature
SectionAll sections Other features Comfort and build Ownership and support Controls and connectivity Performance
Sort byKey features by section Largest differences Feature name
Scored on both products
Other features
Crash stability
Details and evidence for crash stability
Orbitals
Reports of crashes or serious instability are limited; most discussion presents the game as technically dependable.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Originality
Details and evidence for originality
Orbitals
The anime presentation gives the game a clear identity, but its structure and several mechanics remain visibly indebted to Hazelight-style adventures.
20 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Handheld play suitability
Details and evidence for handheld play suitability
South of Midnight
Handheld play suitability was praised through the Steam Deck discussion, where the game was described as a fine portable fit.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Handheld play works, though the split-screen presentation can make the smaller display less ideal than playing on a television.
2 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
World interactivity
Details and evidence for world interactivity
South of Midnight
World interactivity was criticized because one review said environments mainly support only the exact required solution.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Shipboard minigames, playful props, and small side activities give partners reasons to experiment between missions.
7 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Emotional impact
Details and evidence for emotional impact
South of Midnight
Emotional impact was one of the strongest areas, with reviewers highlighting empathy, sorrow, resilience, and lasting personal resonance.
4 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
The presentation and central friendship create genuine warmth, but rushed storytelling prevents the finale from landing equally well for everyone.
9 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Character roster
Details and evidence for character roster
South of Midnight
The cast was praised as memorable, with many characters and monsters leaving an impression despite limited screen time.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
The central duo tends to overshadow the supporting cast, which some reviewers find colorful but lightly developed.
2 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Tutorial quality
Details and evidence for tutorial quality
South of Midnight
Tutorial quality was mixed, with one review praising narrative framing and others criticizing overbearing or overly obvious guidance.
3 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Character development
Details and evidence for character development
Orbitals
Maki and Omura are likable together, but several critics find their development thin and the supporting relationships insufficiently explored.
2 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Combat system
Details and evidence for combat system
South of Midnight
Combat was the most common weakness, praised in a few reviews for chunky or quick encounters but more often criticized as shallow, basic, or repetitive.
19 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Ship combat adds welcome urgency but can become chaotic or uncomfortable, particularly when missiles and hazards crowd the screen.
5 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Onboarding experience
Details and evidence for onboarding experience
South of Midnight
Onboarding split reviewers: one praised the narrative framing of Hazel learning powers, while another felt the game over-explained and mistrusted the player.
2 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Environmental detail
Details and evidence for environmental detail
Orbitals
Locations, props, and small animated touches reinforce the retro-futurist style and make the world consistently pleasant to explore.
11 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Pacing
Details and evidence for pacing
South of Midnight
Pacing was often praised for momentum and concise runtime, though some reviewers criticized a slow start, rushed ending, or underwhelming finale.
9 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Many enjoy the brisk stream of new situations, while others find parts slow and the final stretch rushed or overstuffed.
17 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Narrative quality
Details and evidence for narrative quality
South of Midnight
Narrative quality was a major strength overall, especially the folklore-driven stories, even though some reviews criticized connective tissue or messy plotting.
15 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
The story provides a warm premise and likable friendship but draws recurring criticism for thin development, derivative ideas, and a rushed finale.
36 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Learning curve
Details and evidence for learning curve
South of Midnight
The learning curve was described as occasionally unclear but not severely punishing once hazards and combat expectations clicked.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
The controls and cooperative goals are easy to grasp, but synchronized platforming can still challenge complete newcomers.
2 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Core gameplay loop
Details and evidence for core gameplay loop
South of Midnight
The chapter loop split reviewers: some liked its focused cadence, while others found the repeated arena-chase-boss structure predictable or stale.
6 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Moment-to-moment play is lively and cooperative, although some critics find its repeated tool interactions less ambitious than its inspirations.
26 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Writing quality
Details and evidence for writing quality
Orbitals
Warm character banter helps, but the script is frequently criticized for familiar ideas, thin setup, and an underdeveloped ending.
3 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Visual effects quality
Details and evidence for visual effects quality
Orbitals
Lighting, transitions, and stylized effects strengthen the playable-anime illusion and make set pieces visually memorable.
3 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Polish
Details and evidence for polish
Orbitals
The audiovisual presentation feels highly polished, while a handful of underdeveloped mechanics and technical rough edges keep it from feeling flawless.
7 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Exploration quality
Details and evidence for exploration quality
South of Midnight
Exploration was mixed: reviewers enjoyed the scenery and light secrets, but several felt linearity and simple detours limited discovery.
6 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Linear stages still reward curiosity with playful details, hidden rooms, and activities, though exploration remains secondary to cooperative puzzles.
14 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Immersion
Details and evidence for immersion
Orbitals
The close match between cinematics and live play makes the adventure feel like stepping directly into a lost retro anime series.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Fun factor
Details and evidence for fun factor
South of Midnight
Fun factor was mixed, with some reviewers enjoying the journey or jumping around and others finding play tiresome or combat boring.
5 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Most reviewers find the adventure joyful, charming, and consistently fun with a partner, even when individual mechanics or story beats fall short.
56 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Atmosphere
Details and evidence for atmosphere
Orbitals
Its playful, cozy spacefaring atmosphere and abundant charm soften several reviewers' complaints about the story and mechanics.
30 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Frame rate stability
Details and evidence for frame rate stability
Orbitals
The intentionally stylized frame cadence generally supports the anime illusion, while technical performance is described as mostly smooth.
7 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Platforming precision
Details and evidence for platforming precision
South of Midnight
Platforming was broadly serviceable and sometimes tight or forgiving, but several reviews found it bland, repetitive, or limited.
5 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Platforming is mostly responsive and forgiving, but tandem precision sections and occasional hitbox issues can cause frustration.
8 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Gameplay mechanics
Details and evidence for gameplay mechanics
South of Midnight
Reviewers generally found the basic systems functional or purposeful rather than ambitious, with some seeing solid adventure fundamentals and others noting familiar design.
4 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Its grappling, liquid, and beam tools combine in clever cooperative ways, but some reviewers wish the best ideas were explored more deeply.
30 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Art direction
Details and evidence for art direction
Orbitals
The retro anime art direction is the clearest consensus strength, convincingly recreating the look and texture of late-'80s and '90s animation.
37 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Dialogue quality
Details and evidence for dialogue quality
Orbitals
The leads' banter, puns, and constant chatter are charming to many reviewers but grating to a smaller group, especially in English.
5 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Content variety
Details and evidence for content variety
Orbitals
The game introduces ideas rapidly and often feels inventive, but several reviewers say later sections reuse concepts or abandon promising mechanics too quickly.
21 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Graphics quality
Details and evidence for graphics quality
Orbitals
Orbitals is repeatedly called stunning in motion, with its 3D scenes and animated cinematics blending into an unusually convincing playable anime.
32 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Difficulty balance
Details and evidence for difficulty balance
South of Midnight
Difficulty balance was uneven across reviews: some found it fair and challenging, while others saw abrupt combat spikes or a flat curve.
4 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
The challenge is usually forgiving and family-friendly, though precision platforming and later ship sequences can frustrate less experienced pairs.
42 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Bug frequency
Details and evidence for bug frequency
Orbitals
Technical blemishes appear occasionally, including awkward hitboxes and isolated glitches, but most reviewers do not consider them severe.
5 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Animation quality
Details and evidence for animation quality
Orbitals
The hand-drawn cinematics and deliberately anime-like movement are repeatedly described as gorgeous, authentic, and unusually seamless with gameplay.
29 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Innovation
Details and evidence for innovation
Orbitals
Reviewers praise the steady flow of creative setups, yet often note that promising concepts disappear before reaching their full potential.
16 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Camera behavior
Details and evidence for camera behavior
Orbitals
The camera is generally workable, though some sequences make hazards or platforming action harder to read.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Movement feel
Details and evidence for movement feel
Orbitals
Running, jumping, dashing, and character animation generally feel responsive and expressive, making basic traversal enjoyable.
4 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Comfort and build
Mission design
Details and evidence for mission design
Orbitals
The compact mission structure moves quickly between puzzles, traversal, and ship sequences, though some objectives feel underused.
2 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Puzzle design
Details and evidence for puzzle design
Orbitals
Cooperative puzzles are clever, varied, and satisfying when both players synchronize, but a repeated criticism is that many solutions are too simple.
47 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Level design
Details and evidence for level design
South of Midnight
Level design split opinion, with some praising comfort or scenery and others criticizing railroading, strict linearity, or repetitive structure.
5 supporting reviews · Mixed evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Stages are visually distinct and packed with changing scenarios, although later areas sometimes feel compressed or less fully developed.
21 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Boss design
Details and evidence for boss design
South of Midnight
Boss design was one of the stronger gameplay areas, with many reviewers praising spectacle, story integration, or variety despite some formulaic or weak fights.
9 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Boss encounters stand out when piloting, shooting, and shipboard tasks force both players to coordinate under pressure.
5 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Sound design
Details and evidence for sound design
Orbitals
Sound effects and ambient audio support the tactile tools and spacefaring atmosphere without drawing consistent complaints.
4 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
World-building
Details and evidence for world-building
Orbitals
The cassette-futurist setting is visually distinctive, but reviewers often want more depth behind its communities, technology, and late-game revelations.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Ownership and support
Replay value
Details and evidence for replay value
Orbitals
The compact length and missed activities encourage some immediate replays, while limited mechanical depth reduces the incentive for others.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Value for money
Details and evidence for value for money
South of Midnight
Value for money was generally positive when framed as a short, memorable or Game Pass-friendly experience, though some reviewers warned the $40 price may feel steep.
7 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
The polished co-op adventure earns recommendations from many reviewers, but its short length makes the asking price a meaningful concern for some buyers.
2 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Controls and connectivity
Menu usability
Details and evidence for menu usability
Controls responsiveness
Details and evidence for controls responsiveness
South of Midnight
Responsiveness was mixed: one reviewer liked Hazel's movement feel, while others cited snappiness, lock-on, input, or attack-delay issues.
5 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
Movement and tool use are widely considered responsive and intuitive, helping failures feel tied to coordination rather than unreliable input.
11 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Voice acting
Details and evidence for voice acting
Orbitals
The lead performances receive strong praise for fitting the retro-anime tone, though some reviewers prefer Japanese audio to the chatty English dub.
8 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Protagonist appeal
Details and evidence for protagonist appeal
Orbitals
Maki and Omura's upbeat chemistry is widely liked, although their relentless chatter and limited depth divide some reviewers.
20 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Performance
Performance optimization
Details and evidence for performance optimization
Orbitals
Performance is generally smooth and polished, with only scattered technical issues reported across the reviewed builds.
5 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Soundtrack quality
Details and evidence for soundtrack quality
South of Midnight
The soundtrack was one of the strongest consensus positives, praised for Southern genres, vocal storytelling, and memorable implementation.
17 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Orbitals
The energetic retro-anime soundtrack—especially the opening and title themes—is repeatedly singled out as a presentation highlight.
20 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Evidence available for one product
Other features
Accessibility options
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for accessibility options
Checkpoint system
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for checkpoint system
Co-op experience
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for co-op experience
Orbitals
Cooperation is the heart of the game: asymmetric roles, shared problem-solving, and constant coordination make it especially rewarding with a compatible partner.
46 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Collectibles
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for collectibles
Orbitals
Hidden finds and unlockable ship activities add light optional exploration, though they are not presented as a major source of depth.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Couch co-op quality
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for couch co-op quality
Orbitals
Local split-screen play is a major strength, turning the compact campaign into an easy recommendation for couples, friends, and families sharing a couch.
6 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Enemy variety
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for enemy variety
Facial animations
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for facial animations
Family friendliness
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for family friendliness
Orbitals
Reviewers often recommend it for family play because the tone is warm and the systems are forgiving, despite a few demanding coordination tests.
3 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Flying mechanics
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for flying mechanics
Orbitals
Dividing piloting and gunnery between two players creates memorable teamwork, even if visibility and late-game pressure can make flight frustrating.
5 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Game length
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for game length
Orbitals
The roughly compact campaign leaves many players wanting more; some appreciate the focus, while others consider the ending abrupt and the price harder to justify.
8 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Horror tension
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for horror tension
HUD clarity
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for HUD clarity
Lore depth
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for lore depth
Mission variety
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for mission variety
Online stability
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for online stability
Orbitals
Online co-op is available and generally serviceable in the reviews that discuss it, with few recurring connection complaints.
2 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Progression system
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for progression system
Side character depth
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for side character depth
Skill tree depth
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for skill tree depth
Split-screen quality
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for split-screen quality
Orbitals
The split-screen format supports independent roles well, though duplicated views and crowded action occasionally reduce clarity.
9 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Upgrade system
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for upgrade system
South of Midnight
The upgrade system earned praise in one review for later enhancements that made positioning and cooldown management more interesting.
1 supporting review · Limited evidence
Browse product reviews for South of Midnight
Controls and connectivity
Age appropriateness
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for age appropriateness
Orbitals
Reviewers generally see the adventure as approachable for younger players, while noting that a few coordinated challenges can test novices.
3 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Comfort and build
Map and navigation design
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for map and navigation design
Multiplayer design
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for multiplayer design
Orbitals
Asymmetric responsibilities keep both players involved and make communication essential, although the game requires a second player at all times.
6 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
User interface design
Orbitals No score yet
Details and evidence for user interface design
Ownership and support
Platform-specific feature support
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for platform-specific feature support
Orbitals
Switch 2 features help partners connect and play, though their usefulness depends on the chosen local or online setup.
6 supporting reviews
Browse product reviews for Orbitals
Save system reliability
South of Midnight No score yet
Details and evidence for save system reliability